But not publishing your advancements harms the community greatly. Its like building your product entirely with open-source software (the published work of other researchers) and not contributing back.
But not publishing your advancements harms the community greatly. Its like building your product entirely with open-source software (the published work of other researchers) and not contributing back.
Apple built a proprietary product using open source technology, and are now building proprietary products using open ML research.
But it seems they're doing so for their own profit, not to benefit the open source and research communities.
You say it as its somehow contradictory. Open Source licences allow (LGPL etc), and some even welcome (BSD, MIT, Apache) creating proprietary software based on open source technologies.
Besides, Apple also did extend open source technologies (as open source) a hell of a lot. Webkit past Apple is 100x bigger/fancier/better than the puny KHTML it started from. Tons of LLVM work, especially all the early stuff, has been sponsored by Apple. Swift was made Open Source just recently...
I think that philosophy will continue as they use ML tools. They might share the ML equivalent of plumbing like Webkit/LLVM/Swift, but probably not improvements to the user experience like Siri's brain.
So? Why should they open source and commoditize their core product?
Besides, I don't know any company that did it and got much out of it, except for some gratitude from OSS fans.
My impression is that Apple invested vastly more in the closed parts of OS X than the open parts.
It's been effectively TiVo'ed, or turned into shared-source-ish instead of open enough to run it as a real OS.
Here is the kernel: http://opensource.apple.com/source/xnu/xnu-3248.60.10/ What's above it is not rocket science and the argument could be made that it would hurt apple open-sourcing it. (Whether it's true or not is irrelevant, it's a valid argument). But this research is not.