That'd be like re-scoring the 1890 World Series based on today's MLB rulebook.
That'd be like re-scoring the 1890 World Series based on today's MLB rulebook.
You know its bad when the US Treasury department even disagrees with the EU commission
The US Treasury may be biased in favor of their constituent, whose CEO recently claimed is the largest taxpayer in the country,[0] and other constituents in similar circumstances.
[0] http://www.washingtonpost.com/sf/business/wp/2016/08/13/2016...
And so far, the US Treasury considered this income as "not taxed", meaning it would have been taxed at the corporate US tax rate when and if moved to the US.
Which is why Apple hasn't moved that money to the US, and has something like $190 billion sitting outside the US.
So the treasury is being extremely disingenuous here, they just want to be the ones to tax this income.
You can't be on the side of "pay taxes for the sake of paying taxes because..... society and fairness!" without having an opinion on who and what your expropriated productivity is supporting
Nobody at Apple or the Treasury Dept said that pledge for 13 years of their life to support roads in Ireland
So, no, it is most definitely not their prerogative, just as it isn't the prerogative of the German or Irish government to tax Apple on their US income.
Just to clarify, money that is taxed outside the US gives you a credit towards your US taxes. So if the money is taxed at 2% in Ireland, and then repatriated into the US, they would still be taxed on the difference between the 35% US corporate tax rate and the 2% they've already paid. Now if Apple has to pay Ireland 12.5% instead of the 2% it's paying now, the US would still get the remaining 22.5%.
The down side of this approach is that some times big corporations don't pay taxes and then citizens have to put money for the fines. So the final result depends on how corrupt is the government, how much it wants to protect the corporations and how much hate it will accept from their citizens.
Well, that's like, your opinion, man.
The EU Commission usually doesn't put the hammer down because of trivialities, especially when they are as politically hot as this is. If they push, it's because they're pretty certain that they have grounds (and political support across the Union) for it.
In addition, EU directives are often relatively generic, giving grounds for 1) different national approaches and 2) flexible interpretation by the courts. When courts are called to have their say, they usually follow the political climate pretty faithfully. I can tell you the appetite for a tax shakedown of multinationals is huge in Europe at the moment.
Should Ireland weasel out of this ruling they will face ostracism elsewhere, at a time when they can ill afford it (being one of the countries that will suffer the most if Brexit is not resolved in an amicable manner). They will try (they have to, to save face), but it's unlikely that they will succeed. The party is over.
> The EU commission is not supposed to have any say over tax issues
Au contraire: rules against industrial state-sponsoring have been on the books since Maastricht, I believe. One of the main critiques of the EU is exactly that this straight-jacked national governments, which found themselves without powerful levers to manage their economies. In practice, these rules have been selectively applied, depending on the political climate. Such climate is now very unfavourable towards "onshore tax havens".
> In practice, these rules have been selectively applied, depending on the political climate.
What a really bad practice. I think it's true, too, and not just in the EU (though it may be more obvious in that case.) I can't understand why people wonder how Brexit passed.
It's not really that different from Common Law (aka "this is the law, until enough judges say it's not"). Besides, the alternative would have seen even more people crying the "EU Soviet" had taken sovereignty away.
2017 is an election year in France and Germany; and both elites have an interest in tightening EU policy against external forces (US, Brexit etc). All indicators are against Ireland and Apple.
> that will be thrown out on
> appeal to the European
> courts, mark my words
And if it's not, you'll accept it's not bullshit, or?TBH, it's about damn time Ireland gets the bill for 25 years of thinly-veiled dumping. Luxembourg and Netherlands should be next on the list.
Facts established.