Why School Reform Is Impossible
papert.org
papert.org
The problem with comments like this is that they depend on what you mean by "structure." Although I want to agree with it, I do so only because I think of "structure" as the basic idea behind the school day: you go to class for six to eight hours, divided into chunks of about an hour each and by subject, and then you go home. As near as I can tell, that's been the basic form of school since the formalization of public education.
But one could easily be talking about structure as something else, like the way teachers are hired and paid.
One problem with the idea of reforming a school's "grammar" is that a) schools are so vast and b) the stakeholders in schools, most notably teachers and their unions, have a greater stake in schools than any other. That's one reason I linked to all the articles here: http://jseliger.com/2009/11/12/susan-engel-doesnt-get in a post on how "Susan Engel doesn’t get the problems with schools, but she’ll tell us to “Teach Your Teachers Well” anyway." The problems with public education are largely structural, but probably have more to do with the way teachers are rewarded and incentivized than any other factor. At least that's what the educational research of the last decade or so seems to show.
Although you might over time be able to change that, I'm not sure you'll be able to change everything. For example, lots of people complain (justifiably) about grade inflation and other aspects that are problematic about grades. But what are you supposed to do instead? There's not anything major or obvious, as discussed here: http://jseliger.com/2010/02/17/the-validity-of-grades .
If the kids who do not want to be there, were not forced to, the mission of teachers would move away from what it is now: discipline, and back to what it was before compulsion, education.
http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=11653
When individual reformers can't change things you need systematic reform. That's exactly where education is right now.
In that Alan Greenspan book that was posted, he remarked that his father was infuriated that some of his homework involved painstakingly coloring in maps for hours, because he considered it useless. I don't know about history, but in art classes we would painstakingly spend hours making little patches of different textures. And do things like draw without looking at the page.
One person's waste of time is another person's education. We might be able to come up with the best education to get someone into med school, but it's much harder to come up with an education that is most likely to make someone "successful."
If people have power to shop, they don't all eat the same foods or wear the same wardrobes. Neither should we expect learners with the power to shop to all choose the same educations. As you correctly say, "One person's waste of time is another person's education." (By the way, that mention of drawing exercises is an especially apt example.)
Some schools want to prepare students for college and others just want to get off the D-list of NCLB.
If anything schools should do what they were outlined to do 200 years ago. Provide a baseline of education. If you want additional classes provide them after school or on the weekends. If you've passed the baseline then there is no need to stick around for 2-3 years. Get out, go to college or get an apprenticeship.