How did laws evolve? Why do we punish theft anyway?
What Apple (and Google, Microsoft, probably others) is doing is certainly immoral. It's likely also illegal.
To use your theft example, think about a Robin Hood type situation; should we overlook sidestepping of the law when it fits with our morals and squishies? No. The law is the law.
That edge cuts both ways. In some ways it supports your argument. In others it does not. Introducing morality makes your argument totally different (and, in this case, irrelevant until the United States and Ireland adopt socialism). I'm a bloody liberal and I'm saying that; we can't expect capitalist entities to operate in anything other than their own self interest or we actually don't want capitalism. Can't have it both ways. How do you define fair for a corporate person?
I'm very intentionally avoiding commenting upon the specific situation aside from saying it's weird to come at this morally when discussing a paper entity with clearly defined goals within a particular system of government.
(Especially in a "common law" jurisdiction!)
Yes, morals should not play a role when --applying-- the law. But the reason the law exists is ultimately a moral one. When the punishment is flexible, the judge will normally apply moral arguments to support a more lenient or harsh sentence.
Why did we determine at one point that we should punish theft? Maybe we were wrong and should repeal those laws.
I think you will have a very hard time doing this and most counterarguments will be moral ones.
Ever ask yourself why?
Anyway, it's corporate tax law. The assumption that a corporation is being unfair by using every legal remedy available to it disagrees with how capitalism is supposed to work, or so they tell me, and I really don't care. I literally ran out of steam on making this point while typing this comment because it's 3:30am and matters approximately zero, so I have to ripcord on this. Sorry.
And then they take that and give us 0.005% of their profits in return. Thank you for the generosity? No.
This form of aggressive, "everyone for himself" capitalism works, for a definition of works equal to making certain people rich beyond their dreams. Why should the common man support that? For a phone?
Good night :)
You can't have fair corporate expectations and capitalism. They are mutually exclusive and every case of corporate leadership trading value for moral causes can likely be successfully fought on fiduciary grounds. Capitalism is not aggressive. It just is. The incentives are created in a certain way. This is like saying you'd rather play chess if there was a third color; there's nothing wrong with wanting to play that game instead, but let's not call it chess any more. Dig it?
I don't even disagree with you entirely (again: liberal! Look at me typing this conservative wet dream!), I'd just rather see you make the anticapitalist case as opposed to appealing to morals.
If you ran a corporation in the United States and volunteered to pay more taxes on moral grounds you'd very likely be in breach of fiduciary duty if someone pressed the issue. That's what I'm saying. We have built a certain house and we can debate whether it's a good house, but we also can't be surprised and morally outraged when the incentives of the system are followed to their extremes.
Fair corporate expectations and capitalism are not mutually exclusive. If the result will not be called "capitalism" is not so important for me.
I don't want to make an anti-capitalist case, because I am not opposed to it, but rather certain aspects and behaviors. I think you're arguing that those are intrinsic parts of capitalism.
The money that Apple is sitting on could have been used for many positive things for the citizens of Ireland. Their government and Apple robbed them of that money for 6000 jobs, the taxes they produce and probably some administrative income.
Corporations are not above society. They exist thanks to individuals and infrastructure built with taxes.
I think the idea is to have a level playing field, where everyone pays x%. There could be rebates for some categories of companies, but not for ONE company which is rich anyway.
Nonsense. The reason Apple and those other companies are in Ireland in the first place is because of those deals. That's why the EU is trying to shut it down - the EU is the cartel charging high prices (taxes), and Ireland is the member undercutting them.
I don't think there's anything wrong with what the EU is doing, assuming they have the authority under the treaties, but painting this as a government against its people is just wrong.
The issue here isn't Ireland being at 12.5% which they are free to use - it is the special treatment Apple and I assume other large corporations are getting which is being viewed as unfair