Proper and correct economic analysis explicitly concerns itself with positive statements. These are statements that are factual and/or scientific. In this case, it would be things like estimating the maximum life times earnings of the average athlete. You can gather the data, develop a model, and crunch the numbers to test the model.
The flip side are normative statements: i.e. how things ought to be, what values should be upheld, etc. At that point you are more properly concerned with philosophy, specifically morality, than purely economics. You can certainly use economic data, economic terms, economic models, etc in making your case, but ultimately you are arguing for a normative statement (e.g. what is a "just" or "fair" allocation?).
That's not to say that economists don't make normative statements, they do and all too often. But that's usually politics.