I would say that the surest way to make money for a mathematicaly-inclined person is to graduate in maths from a prestigious school and work in finance.
At least, that's how I feel when I look at alumni from my school. People basically could specialize in finance or CS. Those that went into finance make consistently much more than the others.
I wish I knew that at the time. I thought banks were boring and unappealing places. But now I think finance is one of the rare field (if not the only) where you can earn a lot with a technical, non-managerial position.