>CAA requires the CA to perform additional operation (retrieve and check that DNS record) - not all of the 300-600+ CA's will do this - all it takes is 1 CA and the attacker will get his fraudulent cert from that CA.

CAA seems like another good step that the browsers can demand after a CA fucks up - like google has mandated that some CAs publish Certificate Transparency logs after they've mis-issued a cert, they should also be requiring CAA on threat of being revoked from the browser's trust lists.