Look at HTC. They tried and failed. Dual camera, but the Bokeh is actually a gimmick. It doesn't work.
Look at HTC. They tried and failed. Dual camera, but the Bokeh is actually a gimmick. It doesn't work.
http://petapixel.com/2016/09/07/iphone-7-7-plus-announced-du... (Scroll about halfway down.)
The fake Bokeh from the dual cameras looks like flat circles with Gaussian blur applied. It's a useless gimmick, I can't imagine ruining real photos with this look.
Also my understanding is that there's no blending of images between the two cameras at all. You literally use only one camera or the other. There are existing systems on the market that do this correctly to obtain a much higher quality of image than what is possible with only one camera alone. I would expect Apple to implement this in a future software update.
The way depth information is determined with phase detection autofocus is very similar conceptually with how you'd generate a depth map in software from two separate cameras.
Granted, not all cameras can do phase detection AF at f/8, and at 35mm you have enough DOF that the accuracy of the AF is not that critical. But they can do AF at f/5.6 accurate enough for a 50mm lens. That gives you 8.92mm separation. Still comparable to iPhone.
The microlens/aperture system of the AF masks essentially the back plane of the lens (which follows from the exit pupil) for the AF sensor (interacting mainly with the exit telecentrism of the lens, which is why AF speed and acccuracy can widely vary with lens type, even if the same f-stop is used). Also a reason (besides the fact that many digital sensor designs perform better with telecentric designs due to increased scattering and reflections in the sensor itself compared to film) why modern lenses are almost always strongly telecentric designs.
A completely separate matter is the circle of confusion which is indeed directly related to the aperture of the lens.
(I hope I got most of the optical terms correct, I don't normally discuss this topic in English)
You can trivialy make a great bokeh implementation that's not merely a Gaussian blur.
And I don't see much horrible in these examples -- perfectly fine I'd rather say, if a little overemphasized. But you can get totally blurry bokeh from some lenses, including smeared highlights instead of nice little circles...
Since it's done in software, Apple could use a more uniform circle kernel instead of a Gaussian kernel to do a more authentic bokeh style.
It's not even out yet! How do you if its any better?
But, it is Apple, so I'm sure people will buy them. Missing 3.5mm jack and all...