Is Nagios Enterprise Worthy?
linux.com
linux.com
Ideally there would be one separate, modular system for collecting data and nagios, cacti, etc would all use that.
On the other hand, if you're looking for something less ugly / dated from the architecture point of view, maybe you'll like http://www.shinken-monitoring.org/ ; I never actually got around to deploying it, but the docs look quite good (and it is nagios-compatible, so theoretically there's an easy upgrade path).
http://munin.ping.uio.no/ping.uio.no/tetra.ping.uio.no.html
Myself I use nagios, but I don't do any graphing, i've set up a couple of nice templates making it easy to add and remove services and computers, and I get SMS alerts when things go down. When we get more traffic I think I will look more into munin.
You might want to try Icinga (http://www.icinga.org) instead (no idea how to pronounce it though). It's a fork of Nagios that is supposed to solve some of the issues that supposedly surround Nagios. Haven't used it myself yet though...