Apologies if it sounded overly critical. I actually did read the whole thing. I like the technique. It is very very appealing. I just have a hard time finding evidence in real projects where it has worked.
My complaint is akin to the modern complaints on the gang of 4 patterns. Individually they make compelling arguments and if you follow the discussion, it is appealing.
And I don't want to throw out the baby, so to speak. I think all of these make fine guidelines. We are just an industry that seems hellbent on finding prescriptive directions where it is becoming apparent none exist.