Doing it one stock at a time might raise some eyebrows; it sounds close to insider trading. But it's accepted that people who bet on interest rates will gather lots of data--since every economic indicator you can imagine will have some effect on rates, it's both impossible to be a true "insider" and impossible not to have some degree of insider information.
That's not the definition of "insider trading". Insider trading is you trading on your company's info - the company is free to do so. For example, Google employees can't trade Rackspace on knowledge that Google is about to make a big deal with Rackspace. Google, on the other hand, is free to do so.
From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insider_trading
"In the United States and many other jurisdictions, however, "insiders" are not just limited to corporate officials and major shareholders where illegal insider trading is concerned, but can include any individual who trades shares based on material non-public information in violation of some duty of trust. This duty may be imputed; for example, in many jurisdictions, in cases of where a corporate insider "tips" a friend about non-public information likely to have an effect on the company's share price, the duty the corporate insider owes the company is now imputed to the friend and the friend violates a duty to the company if he or she trades on the basis of this information."
I wasn't aware that a corporation could trade based on insider knowledge. That seems very unlikely; it would imply that, e.g. Boesky was busted because his fund was organized as a limited partnership. And wouldn't a corporation with one owner be equivalent to that owner in terms of economic interest? Could I just form byrneseyeview Inc. to take advantage of my insider knowledge?
Do you have a source for the statement that corporations can engage in insider trading?
It would be, however, illegal for employees, shareholders or indeed anyone hearing about Google's intentions about the purchase to buy those options, as they would be breaking their duty of trust to Google by doing so. This holds regardless of the legal status of the entity in question -- a corporate shareholder getting privileged information from Google before the announcement would be just as screwed as an employee.
But in this case, the company trading on credit card data is clearly analogous to a Google employee, not to Google. They have material information about the prospects of another company, and they use that information to trade.
If you are a secretary working for Google, and overhear talks about the buyout and proceed to load yourself on the stock, SEC is going to want to have a word with you.
> I assumed that a deal with Rackspace meant a purchase of Rackspace products.
I don't think this would be illegal either -- with whom would Google break it's duty of trust if they bought half of Rackspace just before announcing a large deal?
> They have material information about the prospects of another company, and they use that information to trade.
I have material information of the prospects of every company I trade -- I wouldn't trade them without. What turns this into illegal insider trading is receiving that information from a source that is bound by duty of trust to not speak about it. As long as the material information about the prospects of a company does not originate from the company in question, or anyone else bound to not divulge it, it's not insider trading.
When visa data mines credit card transactions, the information so gained can be freely used to whatever purpose without fear from insider trading accusations.
That being said, I do not think it's moral or right -- the laws just were written before large-scale data mining was feasible.
with whom would Google break it's duty of trust if they bought half of Rackspace just before announcing a large deal?
This may be accurate. I was under the impression that insider trading referred to possessing and using information that would have a material effect on the stock price. i.e. nobody's "duty of trust" is breached if a cab driver overhears his rider talking about a big deal, but I'd assume that the cab driver could get in trouble for acting on the information. If it's really about trading based on information obtained through a breach of trust, you end up in an odd situation: either any breach makes all trades insider trades (i.e. executive tells information to his secretary, who leaks it to a journalist) or any non-duty-bound link in the chain obviates the trust issue (X tells it to Y who tells it to Z--who is overheard by A, who sells the tip to B, who makes the trade.)
Yes, but that's because it's your information that you're buying said company.
However, there are other rules that apply to corporate take-overs. In the US, you have to disclose when you reach a certain ownership level. (And no, you can't avoid that by colluding with other people.)
> This may be accurate. I was under the impression that insider trading referred to possessing and using information that would have a material effect on the stock price.
That's why I posted the definition and link.
> i.e. nobody's "duty of trust" is breached if a cab driver overhears his rider talking about a big deal, but I'd assume that the cab driver could get in trouble for acting on the information.
Actually, the person who was overheard violated the breach of trust.
> If it's really about trading based on information obtained through a breach of trust, you end up in an odd situation: either any breach makes all trades insider trades (i.e. executive tells information to his secretary, who leaks it to a journalist)
Huh? There's at least one obvious breach of trust in that chain.
Yes, any breach makes the resulting trades insider trades. No, that doesn't imply that all trades involve such breaches.
It doesn't matter what kind of transaction Google and Rackspace are doing - it's illegal for Google employees to trade on this information and legal for Google to do so. In other words, Google employees can't trade on news of a Google deal to buy Rackspace the company or Rackspace equipment/services. Google the company is free to trade in both circumstances.
> But in this case, the company trading on credit card data is clearly analogous to a Google employee, not to Google. They have material information about the prospects of another company, and they use that information to trade.
Not at all. Insider trading is defined as improper use of corporate information by employees. Companies are free to act on their information.
It doesn't make sense to define "insider trading" as use of "improper information", let alone "non public information". Remember - a huge fraction of trades are based on non-public information.
For example, I may think that the iPad is a disaster. That's not public information, yet it doesn't make sense to restrict my ability to trade on it.
The notion of running a credit card company basically for free as a way to get information about the economy and made MUCH more profitable trades in the financial markets really appeals to me.
Friend of mine has been working on using google trends/blogs as such an indicator, but its a lot harder to tease tradable information out of that sort of data.
I saw something on here a while about a "marketplace for data" - I can't remember what it was called - but it make me wonder how one would determine the price for a data feed or open source intelligence - it seems that a fair price for a data stream should be how much of a profit you can make by trading against people who don't have access to the data.
But it seems to me that if monitoring revenues of retailers was a really big advantage you could do almost as well by conducting a small well designed survey like the FED does. VISA's volume of data is probably deep into large N range of the sigma/sqrt(N) sampling error.