Look at Hyper Light Drifter. Every one who's seen that game agrees that it looks amazing, among the best looking games of the year (a year which includes technical powerhouses like Doom, Uncharted 4 and Overwatch).
In previous years, games like Fez, Superbrothers and Hotline Miami have gotten similar accolades. Even a game which is adheres to super-strict arbitrary pixel art restrictions like Shovel Knight was highly praised.
If people didn't particularly appreciate the art on the author's game, I'm going to say that it has very little to do with the fact that it used pixel art. The "pixel tax" is fictional.
Don't see how you're disagreeing with the parent comment with these examples.
"I think this critique is just plain wrong on its face" is a critique of the article.
Some years later, I realized that I'd logged as many hours in UT99 as I had in emulated playthoughs of Super Metroid and Chrono Trigger, not because the graphics of UT99 were amazeballs (which they were for their time), but because like Super Metroid and Chrono Trigger, UT99 was actually _fun to play_. But when I attempted convey that idea -- that perhaps graphics were not the sole driver of fun factor -- to a game dev who had moments before been bitching about the hacks his team had to do make 3d performant on the Playstation 2, he responded that nope, a game _has_ to be 3d, or it isn't any good.
Is that a silly attitude? Sure. But it still exists. And to dismiss the possibility of such an attitude I think misses the author's point that it is more important to focus on making the best game art one can in the medium to hand, than to focus on an art style that arose from past limitations over everything else.
1. http://andreaspapathanasis.blogspot.com/2015/05/the-tech-arm...
Also, why did the dev have to pull crazy hacks to make 3d performant on the PS2? I mean, if he was trying for something particularly impressive, or xbox-level graphics, sure, but the PS2 was built for manipulating polygons. It was, in a very real sense, the last console that was so aggressively optimized for one use case.
As for the game dev, I don't know, I didn't ask. I might be mis-remembering and he might have been bitching about the PS1 instead of the PS2. shrug
While we're discussing how high tech isn't required in a game, I feel the need to say that they aren't mutually exculsive, either.
That's fair. I think part of the whole pixel art thing is a backlash against modern graphics tech, born of one-too-many experiences with a game that, while using the latest and greatest tech to achieve visually-stunning results, was no fun to play. Taken to the extreme, it can easily become a reverse-pixel-tax attitude: A game using modern graphics tech wont be fun, or at least, not as fun as it could have been.
Such an attitude is as equally silly as a pixel-tax attitude, and I think part of what drove the the author to write the original article is realizing such.
Meanwhile, the latest Call of Duty makes a hojillion dollars, still running on a heavily modified Quake 3 engine, with relatively unimpressive graphics for its time. Meanwhile meanwhile, Valve makes another smash hit, still running off of a heavily modified Quake 1 engine.
A lot of the PS2's speed came from vector processing; not sure how great the tools were for taking advantage of vector math. Didn't code on one myself. Also possible they were just using too many polygons; it's easy to kill your performance when you push your polygon numbers too high, or if you have too much overdraw and you blow past the pixel fill rate. (The design of the game had various animations happening in the background, which no player could ever see because of course you're paying attention to the Tetris board in the middle...not my idea; I just implemented what they asked for.)
I didn't have performance problems on the Game Boy Advance because even though my CPU was slower, I was in 2d-land. It was funny to me that they eschewed the C++ engine and rewrote their in C because "performance!", while they ended up with performance problems and I didn't, but what can you do...
Or something.
Neat story, anyways.
The Diablo vs. FFTA example in the article demonstrates it well: Despite Diablo coming out earlier, while 2D art was very much a well-cultivated thing, the artists just didn't know how to get it right (too low contrasts, too much dithering, …). FFTA, meanwhile, just looks beautiful.
I also agree with his criticism of Goldeneye vs Grim Fandango. However, which of those games was more successful?
Sometimes good art doesn't sell as well as flashy effects that may look antiquated in 5-10 years.