Hacker News Reader

Comment by fma | Hacker News Reader

If it weren't for unions we'd all still be working Saturdays. But we all know unions are only for the good for nothing & the lazy.

http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2015/sep/...

View on HN

If it weren't for unions, we'd still have a competitive manufacturing industry that would be allowed to reward competence rather than seniority.

Unions stagnated decades ago and have achieved little more than strangling many of the industries they are involved in.

> a competitive manufacturing industry that would be allowed to reward competence rather than seniority.

Because that's how it was for labourers before unions?

Yes, life with unions sucks. But life without unions sucks even more.

Is there any real evidence of this that's not from conservative talk radio?

It's amazing how workers, who got fired by the hundreds of thousands, voluntarily gave up pensions only to lose their jobs, dealt with numerous health issues and cancers working in horrible conditions, even in modern times, and still get blamed.

Yeah.. and if it weren't for unions most of us would've been working from the age of 7 or so in a country with no safety regulations. Imagine how competitive those businesses would be though, oh boy! Sorry if the unions in your particular area/industry don't live up to your expectations, but unions have done far more good than bad, and it's been over a lot longer than decades.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com