Tell HN: My new product, Dotpack, a .NET binary packer
daeken.com
daeken.com
Update: Looks like they consolidated all of their products (including "Postbuild for .NET") into their Application Studio. [http://www.xenocode.com/]
Kudos on LMZA - I wish Silverlight would have used that instead of just zip. It'd make a pretty big impact on size.
As for LZMA, it has a huge impact for sure, but until assembly merging and dead code analysis are in place, the impact on Silverlight assemblies is going to be pretty slim.
Dotpack does wonders on standalone binaries as it stands (compresses NVidia FX Composer to just over 20% of its original size, for instance), but most Silverlight assemblies only get a 10-20% decrease right now. I'm looking forward to getting the Silverlight side stable and as high quality as the standalone side.
I reviewed {smartassembly} back in 2007 (http://neosmart.net/blog/2007/smartassembly/) and till now it remains hands-down the best obfuscation and post-release-processing tool for .NET applications.
For larger projects the obfuscation can break the product. It's tedious work, but you can manually exclude functions from the obfuscation procedure until you can find out where things went wrong.
Edit: For the record, I performed quite a bit of reverse-engineering on Magic: The Gathering Online, which uses SmartAssembly for obfuscation. Despite it being heavily obfuscated, an hour with Mono.Cecil got me a clean binary with placeholder names. That is simply unacceptable.
ExePack == DotPack
same functionalities .. but one is "Product" and other is opensource project ..
Don't accuse people without evidence, especially long-standing members of the community like Daeken, of stealing. The fact that you spammed Daeken's blog with comments promoting exepack (forcing him to disable comments) doesn't help either.
Then again, some of your comments were pure gold. For example:
"Your product" name is DotPack and open source ExePack ; Pack part of the name the same . coincidence ? To much coincidence in this case .
(FYI, I've worked on a portion of DotPack's code, specifically optimizing the LZMA unpacker module, and while that portion was not original code, the original source was a public domain LZMA unpacker. We ended up rewriting practically the whole thing anyways because of how badly it was written. The end result was something like half the size of the original.)
"Your product" name is DotPack and open source ExePack ;
Pack part of the name the same . coincidence ?
To much coincidence in this case .
NM Moscow, Russia
At least a dozen HN readers can attest to the fact that I've been working heavily on this, and two have seen the source first-hand and can confirm that it's original.It's offensive to say the least to have such an accusation come up on your own blog, but eh, such is the internet.