Hacker News Reader

Any reason why you couldn't put a tanker in geo-sync orbit connected to a very (very) long fuel pipe somewhere on earth? The idea being you can pump fuel up instead of launching it?

Kind of like a space elevator for fuel! :)

View on HN

Probably the same reason we can't build a space elevator :)

In didnt say it would be easy, but neither is sending 100 people to mars.

I'm not engineer, but wouldn't a pipe be easier to build than an elevator?

The problem with space elevators is that the cable (or the pipe, as you propose) needs to be able to hold itself together. Imagine taking a 4000 km long elevator cable and holding it up by one end: it would snap under its own weight instantly. That's about what your cable material needs to be able to take. The weight of the car is trivial in comparison.

Does it have to support its entire weight? At some point, won't the pipe have enough centrifugal force that would be supporting it?

The uppermost parts of the pipe (up past GEO) would; that's why it doesn't fall down. However, unless your pipe is strong enough, it'll rip in two, and the part above GEO would fly away and the part below will fall down.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com