Apple Doesn't Owe You Anything.
realdeal.posterous.com
realdeal.posterous.com
..so long as _I_ can do whatever I want with _my_ device. I want to setup a business around breaking phones out of Apple's jail? No problem. I want to create an app store to compete directly with Apple's own? No problem. I want to sell apps directly to users through my website? No problem.
The app store is Apple's service, so they can do whatever they want with it. If they want to lock out competing app stores through software, that's fine. I have a problem with the laws that make circumventing those software locks a crime. Jailbreaking is legally questionable; developing for jailbroken phones is risky, so very few people get in on it. Without those foolish laws, I'm sure we'd have a number of alternatives to Apple's app store, and this whole thing would be a non-issue.
Great example of yes-yes persuasion technique. You made two statements few people can disagree with. Then you threw in a third one that is controversial YET appears to be just as logical as the previous two:
And if you're not developing apps for the platform then you have no grounds on which to bitch and moan.
How come?
Except in the case when Apple has a monopoly that holds back other mobile platforms for which you would like to develop for.
This is not the case, not yet, but some can see it coming, although for obvious reasons I don't think it will ever be a monopoly.
BULL!!
Apple has been using "Apps" to sell its super successful phone. Without its developers and robust App store, the iPhone would hardly be in second place IMO.
Apple OWES US EVERYTHING!
I don't own an iPhone because I like the shitty keyboard or because of AT&T and its limited 3G service. I own one because their app store rocks. That's it really.
So, Apple should be jumping through hoops to help their developers. Sure devs make money, but that's part of the give and take.
We scratch your back, you scratch ours.
The app store process has greatly improved over the last year (after massive complaining), but in my experience Apple puts their interests first in every instance. This is of course their right, and even to be expected, but I am blind to the hoops they've been jumping through.
1) The existence of the App Store and its one-click purchasing, for example, has created business opportunities and revenue that are unprecedented for the amount of effort it takes to enter that market. Guys are making tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars by coding up games on their couch. That everyone is now taking this for granted means one thing: Apple's execution was flawless.
2) The protection of the market so that it remains an impulse-buyers paradise relatively free of buggy software, and completely free of malware, requires an enormous investment in hiring and training reviewers. Sure, developers hate the wait and the uncertainty of approval, but this process is what has made the market as profitable as it is. I can buy an app without fear that it'll steal my bank account #, which apparently can't be said for everything in the Android marketplace.
As you've said, the process has greatly improved over the last year. Consider the fact that this is the first time Apple has done this, and the first time anyone's done it on this scale. That the process has improved even as the submission rate scaled up to thousands of apps per day is incredible.
3) The controlled deployment of APIs, released when they're ready rather than when developers whine for them. This requires restraint and planning that almost no other vendor can pull off. Anyone who's had to re-write entire codebases because Microsoft couldn't decide if today's flavor was COM, DCOM, ActiveX, or .Net can appreciate this.
I doubt that any of the crybabies will appreciate the above, because they think it's all irrelevant if they can't port their Flash game with a mouseclick or write in C#. But they're also only seeing it from their point of view. In the dozens of outraged blog entries that have ascended HN's front page this week, very few show any evidence of looking at it from other points of view, and arguably the most important points of view: Apple's and their customer's.
Apple is looking after their self-interest, and I am looking after mine. I don't see why it falls on a random blogger to tell me whether my self-interests are best served by complaining online or not.
iPhone and iPad will eventually be dominated by cheaper and more open commodities and they can keep their "we don't owe anyone anything" mentality