EFF Asks Court to Block U.S. From Prosecuting Security Researcher
eff.org
eff.org
Matthew Green filed a lawsuit to strike down section 1201 of the DMCA.
https://blog.cryptographyengineering.com/2016/07/28/statemen...
This EFF action is legit, and so is Matthew Green, but the controversy here is entirely synthetic.
What's important to understand about the US court system is that it is by design hugely powerful and subject to almost no outside oversight, but --- because of that power, and the desire not to have Presidents appointing panels of philosopher-kings --- the courts are only allowed to hear cases about live controversies.
So if you're using the courts as an instrument of policy change, the name of the game is finding a favorable live controversy.
This requirement makes sense but can be infuriating. I think most states have this requirement too.
Seems strange to consider it test days but Congress could clarify this in a brief amendment, which might even be possible in these days where "Cyber" is considered "so important"
OTOH there is generally enough flexibility for a court to punt when they don't actually want to address the underlying issue.
This is a reasonable law review article: http://www.tjeffersonlrev.org/sites/tjeffersonlrev.org/files...