When Arthur Scargill appeared before a Parliamentary committee and was asked at what level of loss it was acceptable to close a pit he answered “As far as I can see, the loss is without limits.”
Coal was fatally wounded in the 70s when the industry became more heavily subsidized, less productive (by 6% in 5 years) and failed to implement any meaningful modernization or reform programs (Plan for Coal). By the 1980s it was just too late to save it.
Last week i was going through 1880s articles, and got reason to why banks aren't 'unlimited liability partnerships'. The realities were, they were in the early 1880s. Then one Scottish bank failed and the courts went after widowers and simple retail investors who owned the shares to get claim back assets for depositors for the failed bank. Apparently taking money from widowers then was absolutely terrible. They allowed banks to become limited liability companies shortly after.
Not the best to repeat that today, as bad as limited liability banks can be, it would be worse for them to sue household investors to reclaim deposits, particularly when they can't enforce accountability in the company, being such small investors.
Today if the idea ever caught hold, that old 1880s newspaper would shed light.
To your second point, I come from a mining background, you can find my name on many pit disaster monuments and you can take it from me that that benefit is very much recognised.
[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_mining_in_the_United_Ki...
The current bunch finds it so much easier to just cut a huge check to EDF and China to build an obsolete, centralized big-ass plant. Benefits to occupation levels will be zero outside of Hinkley. We have no sustainable solution for nuclear waste, and one more terrorist target. Facepalm.jpg
There are excellent reasons why it shouldn't. Jobs are a cost of doing something, not a benefit.