I don't know who is agreeing here, but I find people who say this to be looking with some seriously rose-tinted glasses. Mac OS X 10.6 is really not that great. It's hardly as "rock-solid" as people make it out to be.
It's the iOS 6 of OS X. It's the refinement of the most familiar interface before things started changing. That doesn't make it better, just more comfortable for some.
Here's the kicker: it's ugly. It looked good at the time, but looking back on it, it looks clunky. The remaining Aqua elements look out of place and weird, buttons lack consistency, design is all over the map.
10.12 isn't perfect but it's a pretty damn good OS. Mac OS X/OS X/macOS has always been kinda buggy; it's the nature of an OS with a significantly smaller userbase. IMO it's no worse now than it was in 10.6, except it has a ton more features.