EFF: The Entertainment Industry's Dystopia of the Future
eff.org
eff.org
The RIAA/MPAA are co-opting the government into spending taxpayer dollars to enforce the recording industry's licensing policies. It's a crafty but regressive strategy that seems unlikely to be successful in the long term.
Looks like the movie and music industry thinks that file sharing is a threat to society along the lines of terrorism.
However, it would seem that moviemakers who embrace no control would be a greater threat than the renegade filesharers.
They would probably already found a business model that embrace p2p. All it take is for a ruthless media entrepreneur to wreck creative destruction over the existing order of Hollywood.
I think the music industry can get by w/ higher and higher concert prices because each concert/venue is a separate,unique product and people don't mind paying for a band they really like. In the movie industry, although there is a small subset of moviegoers who will go see the same movie 6 times in the theater, the product is completely consistent through each viewing so after a certain point of price hikes, I think less and less people will attend movies in the theater.
They basically said that although artists need to be fairly compensated that piracy is not going to disappear. They also think that government interference should be minimized and that fans will always be better at distribution.
Their suggestion is voluntary collective licensing. Basically artists join licensing organizations and fans pay money to the organization to get the right to legally download music. Artists don't have to join, but non-member artists would be faced with the tough task of collecting money from infringing fans.
They also suggest compulsory licensing for property that owners refuse to license at any cost. They note that the government has done this in other cases. Compulsory licensing was enforced with radio, internet radio, cable/satellite tv, and player pianos.
Links:
http://www.eff.org/wp/better-way-forward-voluntary-collectiv...
http://www.eff.org/pages/making-p2p-legal
Overall the suggestions seem reasonable from my point of view.