My hunch is that the two assumptions will prove incompatible. Complex entities will have complex motivations, like people do.
A true AI born out of a paperclip maximizer would be more likely to spend its time writing hyper-symphonies about paperclips, and majoring in Clippy studies.
On a related theme, I've been kicking around an ontology of technological mechanisms,[1] one element of which is control systems. It's somewhat underappreciated that what made complex and/or highly-scaled systems possible in many cases were systems for either regulating or mitigating processes or discrepencies between parts of systems.
Swingletrees for draught teams, Watt's governor, for his steam engine (and additional tweaking to damp down oscillation tendencies), infrared temperature sensing and gas chromatography in steelmaking.
We figure out how to make a thing go, then we figure out how to make it go where we want.
Even high-speed rail was a bit more about quality control (rail and roadbed specification) and control (wheel truck hunting, pantograph-commutator interactions) than dumping gobs of energy into a rail-wheel system.
________________________________
Notes:
I agree with your point and think we will discover that intelligent systems are by their nature full of interlocking feedback loops with negative controls, and that this is a necessary prerequisite for a system to even be intelligent.
There are many neurons which are exitatory -- they respond when stimulated by others.
There are a large number which are inhibitory. They supress activity of other neurons.
I'm suspecting inhibition is more critical than excitation for consciousness and intelligence.