Here is a great example that got posted here a little while back: http://createyourproglang.com/
Here is a great example that got posted here a little while back: http://createyourproglang.com/
Hell, his "customer reviews" are pulled straight from the tri-color ad copy.
It alternates between blue, black, green, and red. So you're right, it's quad-color.
I was wrong about the source of his quotes being his ad copy. It's actually an unlinked forum where he probably got his friends to write ad copy for him, presuming he didn't do it himself.
What you've got is a perfect opportunity for A/B testing-- check out Patio11's blog or comments here for examples and details.
You can (and should) be tweaking your page, and measuring the results of those tweaks. By keeping the tweaks that bring you better results (and rolling back the ones that don't), your conversion rate (and income) will continue to grow.
It might put people off, I don't know.
Don't discount marketing.
That's the whole point of A/B testing.
The whole "good and interesting information" vs "beautiful graphics" division is a false dilemma. You don't have to choose between them.
And, I'm not even saying that you should have "beautiful graphics".
What I am saying is: you are running a business here. The goal is to make money. There are tools (notably A/B testing) which will make you far more effective at reaching your goals than you currently are.
You're getting lots of valuable (but free) advice from the good folks of HN. It would behoove you to take it seriously.
So if you look like a scam, they're going to assume you are.