Other countries, even large ones, manage to do OK with recounts. I will note that the Florida recount wouldn't have had to happen
at all in 2000 with NPV, since the national vote was clear, only Florida's was iffy.
And how does it protect the country from unqualified presidents? It may have been meant to do that, but at this point it's just a weird way to tally votes. There's no realistic chance these days that the outcome could be changed by electors voting differently from how they're supposed to.
All it accomplishes now is give a handful of states hugely exaggerated importance in the election relative to the rest by making it so that they effectively determine the outcome regardless of the popular vote total.