Sniper attack on Utah substation highlights grid vulnerability
utilitydive.com
utilitydive.com
It is too expensive to bury the distribution network, and while isolated attacks like this are extremely unfortunate, the reality is that they are infrequent enough that physically securing the equipment will cost more than the economic losses to the energy company.
The state of industrial security is laughable, and electronic attacks are much easier to accomplish than physical attacks, simply because you can target geographically distributed locations simultaneously.
It's unfortunate that someone thought it was fun to shoot up some transformers, but just look at the article: up to $1 million in costs for the operator in this incident, versus an estimate of hundreds of billions in damages due to a cyber attack.
It seems like it has a false positive problem (which you allude to) and a response time problem.
The first problem seems almost irrelevant if the response cost is low (because you have drones), the latter problem may be more of an issue. Recent drones can get 45 mph, so depending on what kind of range you expect snipers to have, it's probably possible to have a ring of them around the area such that their 2 min range only just overlaps and be able to cover ~3-4 miles around an installation.
Is 2 minutes too slow of a response time for these facilities? I don't know.
Rural areas will be much easier to secure than urban areas though.
Steal a garbage truck, ram a substation.
You can't protect the grid form physical attacks.
The shooting attacks were so destructive because punching holes in transformers allowed coolant to leak out, forcing those transformers to shut down. Repairing such damage is a lengthy and expensive process. Substation transformers are large, heavy, and complex; you can't fix the damage just by slapping on a quick patch. And buying a replacement takes months.
There's no perimeter security there to speak of - just a chain-link fence, and no bollards or anything else to keep someone from driving over it.
There are plenty of attack vectors available for this sort of thing, though. I'm not sure it's even possible to effectively protect something like this.