But all the "scrypt" ASICs I'm familiar with are limited to computing the nerfed litecoin version anyway.
In general, you can't prevent ASICs unless you maximally utilize commodity hardware.
But what is the point of that?
(as opposed to bcrypt and other systems where an ASIC could be faster than a CPU/GPU)
So rich people (the ones able to buy lots of ASICs and/or memory) will still have an advantage in mining.
So again, what is the point?
If commodity hardware is competitive for mining, then mining power is more likely to be distributed amongst a network of users, rather than owned by a few big players.
You might ask why the network of users doesn't just buy the custom mining hardware. But the economics of it doesn't work out in the long run. If you can build a machine that prints money, why would you sell it to me for less than its lifetime money-printing value?
Specialized hardware goes in the opposite direction in both ways.
Sure.
> So rich people (the ones able to buy lots of ASICs and/or memory) will still have an advantage in mining.
> So again, what is the point?
With non-memory hard hashes, ASICs or GPGPU yield superlinear gain (in hash/s/$) compared to general-purpose CPUs. A 1080 will get you orders of magnitude faster SHA hashing than the pair of i7s you'd get from the same price, and ASICs have an even larger difference.
Also scrypt was designed for password storage, not for workproofing dogecoin.
Scrypt uses memory IO so that you can get "your money's worth" by running on an Intel CPU.
I'm still amazed that people believed that.
We've been pushing general purpose CPU's for decades because there is nothing novel or hard about making single purpose processors.
I didn't realize you could just say random computing terms and people would believe you. "This is memory hard so therefore no ASIC (single purpose processor) could be made because memory is expensive"
I like cryptocurrency but 2012-2014 was seriously like being on crazy pills listening to the fans.
http://cryptorials.io/beyond-hashcash-proof-work-theres-mini...
on how asymmetric PoW avoid this handicap.