Facebook, Instagram and Twitter Provided Data for Surveilling Activists of Color
aclunc.org
aclunc.org
Plus, frankly, most people won't read about the issue or read the article for anything other than the headline put on it, so it generates outrage and postings which leads to funding and legislative action. Not something I like, but its how they work.
Just because the underlying tech functions the same doesn't mean they serve the same purpose. It's all context and that context matters. For example: You can use torrents to distribute legal files and "illegal" files, almost everything about the technology is the same but the end goal is different.
The data that ad companies get is largely a side effect of modern technology, not nefarious behaviour. How that data is then used is the question. We can be critical of the data collection as well on both sides but just because the technology exists and is used elsewhere doesn't give moral justification for targeted intrusion software.
However here governmental entities did not have preferred access! They purchased the preferred access that Geofeedia would happily sell to anyone.
If I understand ACLU's position correctly, it would be more fully stated as "The government should not be allowed to buy preferred access to social media speech for surveillance purposes." or perhaps instead or also "Nobody should be allowed to sell preferred access to social media speech for surveillance purposes."
Which is fine as far as wishes go, but on what principles is this "should" grounded?
What kind of freedom from government (mass) surveillance should we expect for actions that are conducted in public (physically public or electronically public)?
I am sympathetic to the ACLU's goals here and am hoping to find better grounding for them, intellectually, politically, and practically.
- Is a company allowed to sell what an individual willingly provides if the individual agrees to those terms?
- Should an individual who provided personal information expect the company to keep it private by default or expect capitalism by default?
- should a company legally be disallowed to promise/advertise security?
- Is the government allowed to act similarly as any other private company in regards to accessing information?
I'm pretty sure most people would say no to this question (at least, after you gave them some examples). The government is bound by the constitution in ways that private companies are not, for good reason. I'm pretty sure that's the point that the grandparent post was trying to make - that the ACLU should make clear that they are advocating that this is a situation wherein the government doesn't have preferred access, but they should have restricted access.
In ways, I think yes. But I also believe that this is a very important conversation we have to ask ourselves. Theres nothing stopping the bullies of the world from company owned information except the price the companies put on it.
> preamble - Provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare and secure the blessings of liberty for ourselves and our prosperity.
So far so good. We certainly do need to provide for the common defense, and secure the blessings of liberty.
> 4th ammendment is unreasonable searches and seziures
Its quite reasonable considering every other party is capable of it
> 9th ammendment - individuals have unenumerated rights
This might be a stopper. A person may have the right to control the information they willingly gave away and which they specifically agreed to give up control.
2)
Should the government have a standing military capable of lethal force? Should the government be allowed to setup metal detectors and security guards at the fronts of schools? Should the government be allowed to collect information about their citizens?
Should the government be allowed to purchase information from private companies? Should the government be allowed to purchase weapons from private companies? Should the government be allowed contract security jobs to private companies?
These questions arent that contreversial but certainly interesting
>Social media monitoring is spreading fast and is a powerful example of surveillance technology that can disproportionately impact communities of color.
[1] "ACLU exposes Facebook, Twitter for selling surveillance company user data" -- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12688548
[2] "US startup Geofeedia 'allowed police to track protesters'" -- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12693732