If the cost of the produced electricity is competitive, the unit size of the production system doesn't matter much (this metric will account for the differing capital and operating costs of the production systems).
Looking around a bit, I guess nuclear is considered cheaper than geothermal, but for Iceland the fixed costs of dealing with nuclear might be prohibitive (right now they spend nothing on stuff like securing nuclear materials, to add a gigawatt of nuclear, they have to deal with it for a long time, or pay someone else to do it).