New Climate-Friendlier Coolant Has a Catch: It’s Flammable
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
That said, R290 has been around forever and there are huge debates as to whether or not it actually increases the risk of fire in case of an accident. There are many who will retrofit their AC compressors to use R290 instead of the now significantly more-expensive R12 or its incompatible and inferior-cooling R134a alternative.
The argument goes that R134a is warmer enough that it takes less R290 to do the trick. It's a closed, separate system, and the gas itself is largely distributed and not pooled (like a gas tank would be) and there isn't enough of it to actually sustain a fire. It's also claimed that it's simply not as easy to combust as it's made out to be, but I'm not a chemist and I don't know.
CFCs were successful because they are incredibly safe. HFCs are about as safe as CFCs. Now, if every car started to carry something as dangerous as a propane tank, we could expect a lot of people to die (some cars currently do carry propane tanks, and they are less safe because of it).
Anyway, this thing is certainly not as dangerous as propane, or we'd have reliable data by now. The question is, how well tested is it (are there unbiased 3rd party tests?), and how dangerous are we willing to go? (And that F-O link is usually nasty.)
I found people with charred mustaches, first degree hand burns, all from _catastrophic_ gas leak followed by flash explosion inside the cabin. Example video clip: http://motoryzacja.interia.pl/wiadomosci/ciekawostki/news-ta...
Stats: LPG ignition is 8 times _less likely_ than regular gas fire in case of a leak.
so dangerous ...