Edit: Remember, this is HN, not Reddit, keep it civil. And also keep in mind, odds are pretty low you will change anybody's view at this point, especially over comments ;)
Edit: Remember, this is HN, not Reddit, keep it civil. And also keep in mind, odds are pretty low you will change anybody's view at this point, especially over comments ;)
People are more likely to lie about their voting intentions when the media create a climate of moral stigma around their candidate. I am sure this is going to happen in the uk too. The Democrats have run the wrong campaign.
I saw a great "life pro tip" recently: If the News it telling you how to feel, it's not news. Always remember that.
It's not a white/black choice this time around but the social exclusion in some circles of people who support Trump might see something similar in play. That said, it would need to be a pretty big effect to make a difference if the gap is really 6 or 7 points.
I know quite a few in this camp.
> It seems many communities, including SV, have tried to ostracize those with opposing viewpoints. Trump's strength is built on that, whether an individual will be public about it or not. I read somewhere (sorry no source) that this election has seen the fewest bumped stickers/yard signs in recent history.
I'd believe that. It'd be a combination of people not actually liking Clinton enough to want to show support and people being scared of actively showing support for Trump. The Clinton camp has done a decent job of bucketing all Trump supporters as racists assholes so it naturally makes it uncomfortable for people to voice their support. I'm pretty sure that's working as intended.
[0] http://www.realclearpolitics.com/epolls/2008/president/natio...
Would you consider this unwarranted? Not necessarily in a political sense, but by way of the man's earned & self-professed reputation.
How bad do they have to be before the media is given a free pass on being against that person? Is it never acceptable to you?
If it's never acceptable for the media to be against a candidate, they're going to be completely worthless in a variety of situations.
But yeah, ideally the media should as unbiased as it is realitistically possible. If things are truly bad, then they'll be recognized as such without the need to distort the truth. The media can only hurt itself by willfully manipulating the message, since that undermines the public trust on journalists, whose impact on the public is crucially dependent on that trust.
It's a "boy who cried wolf" kinda scenario, or sorta like how everyone rolls their eyes when an "X causes cancer" headline pops up. If journalists choose to trade their credibility for anything else (eye-popping headlines, ads revenue, or subserviency to whomever is bank rolling them) they're paying it with their relevancy in the minds of the public. And if journalists really conceive themselves as on a moral mission, that's the last thing they should do away with.
When they call a spade a spade, the media gains credibility in the next election between two normal candidates.
I'm sure someone will hate this comparison. But really, the republican candidate is a fucking monster this time. It's never been this bad. It's not even a bad comparison anymore. I've always hated when people use it, but this guy wants to do some scary shit.
Take for example the most recent Rasmussen showing Trump winning by 2%. To quote rasmussenreports.com:
"Typically, calls are placed from 5 pm to 9 pm local time during the week."
"After the surveys are completed, the raw data is processed through a weighting program to ensure that the sample reflects the overall population in terms of age, race, gender, political party, and other factors. The processing step is required because different segments of the population answer the phone in different ways. For example, women answer the phone more than men, older people are home more and answer more than younger people, and rural residents typically answer the phone more frequently than urban residents."
Seriously, who answers spam calls at home between 5pm and 9pm? Anyone here? At all? rasmussen and all other poll operators keep their transfer function secret. Its entirely possible their transfer function bears no relationship with who it actually going to show up and vote in November.
Lets pick on a semi-public transfer function from IDB. Their poll shows a dead tie Trump and Clinton both exactly 41%. However check the fine print about their transfer function "Party identification breakdown: (Unweighted) 261 Democrats/261 Republicans/275 Independents; (Weighted) 291/235/271."
Seriously, they believe 23% of republicans are going to stay home on voting day? Seriously? I mean when I was a kid, even Pravda would have been embarrassed to publish something like that. Obviously the editorial board saw a Trump win in the results and ordered the Republican weighting decreased until the printable result was a tie at worst.
Pew claimed in 2015 "When the partisan leanings of independents are taken into account, 48% either identify as Democrats or lean Democratic; 39% identify as Republicans or lean Republican. The gap in leaned party affiliation has held fairly steady since 2009, when Democrats held a 13-point advantage (50% to 37%)." So Pew implies the IDB transfer function should be wildly different, something like 48%/39%/13% than what they actually used to "surprisingly" provide a predetermined result.
Note that for the actual vote in November, plus or minus the usual dead people always voting democratic, the transfer function is very close to 1:1. My vote is counted as one vote, not some weird fractional part of a vote depending on my race or whatever the polling companies are doing.
What you are doing here is taking your facile analysis of what their skew correction might be and using it to speculate that a relatively conservative, information focused publication is trying to influence the vote by lying in a way that won't really do much to influence the vote.
http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/trump-supporters-probabl...
http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/what-could-the-polls-be-...
Probably not.
"So when they see that the media élite is driven out of their mind at the success of Donald Trump it makes them want to root for him. It’s like giving the middle finger to the rest of the country."
http://www.economist.com/blogs/graphicdetail/2016/06/britain...