There's a lot of value in that offering, because there's a huge gap between "enthusiasts reviews" (Anandtech, for example) and "consumer" (Consumer Reports). One is done by enthusiasts for enthusiasts and the other is done by consumers for consumers. The Wirecutter seems to provide "by enthusiasts for consumers".
Let me guess. The one that makes a non-sharp cut that requires the strength of a bodybuilder and doesn't work half the time?
But, yes, they seem to do a good job overall. Honestly, for a lot of things these days, all you want is a succinct recommendation for something decent while understanding the basis of the recommendation.
Except they only last about 6-10mo before they stop producing a reliable cut and you have to throw them out.