The research shows a correlation between intelligence(/education) and not being religious. 30 seconds with Google:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religiosity_and_intelligence#S...
>> Even in more modern times you see very intelligent people with some form of religious belief. From Newton, to Einstein, to Godel, to C S Lewis
I already discussed the problems with arguing single data points for statistical correlations. See my comment on the brother comment of yours.
Again: There seem to be less correlation between intelligence and rationality than we usually think. (At least, as I thought when I was young enough to still have hair. :-) )
(So I am not going to touch the personal arguments. Let me just note that your examples are flawed.
Einstein called himself "agnostic": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religious_views_of_Albert_Eins...
Newton was, well, quite crazy. :-) Also, he was hardly modern, he lived long before evolution was known. Before that, you really needed some form of designer to explain life.
C S Lewis' analytical self reflection don't impress. A bunch of years ago, I read part of a biography and how he chose religion in WWI. His motivation was flawed. Literature insight is something else than rationality.
That said, some of my intellectual idols are religious. E.g. Knuth and Larry Wall.)