While union workers often have less salary disparity, their salaries also tend to be higher overall. The only downside to this is if the "best performers" derive value from their "worse performer" peers being paid less than them.
Or if you're in your twenties or thirties and pretty good at something and want to be paid based on how valuable you are in the market instead of based on your number of years clocking in.
Yes, but how much greater than $X is the question. If median salary goes up, high performers have to come down a lot in order to not run out of money.
Personally, I'd never want to work somewhere where my salary is set by a formula of my "experience" level.