1. votes not being counted properly
2. Improper votes being cast
This seems like it only addresses #1
1. votes not being counted properly
2. Improper votes being cast
This seems like it only addresses #1
Security Requirements
• Only eligible voters may vote, and each eligible voter votes at most once.
• Each cast vote is secret, even if voter wishes otherwise!
-- No vote-selling!
-- No receipt showing how you voted!
• Final outcome is verifiably correct.
• No "trusted parties" – all are suspect! Vendors, voters, election officials, candidates, spouses, other nation-states, ...
Full slide-deck:
https://people.csail.mit.edu/rivest/pubs/Riv16x.pdf
Lots of other great stuff in there, addresses each of these points.
Reading between the lines...
This will be an audit of their internal bookkeeping. Ballots received equals ballots accounted for, number of signatures verified, that sort of thing. It's worth doing. When I served as a poll inspector, we'd proof each other's work, which is normal.
In my jurisdiction, final result is called the ballot summary report, which is approved by our canvassing board, which ultimately certifies the election.
An audit of the actual votes cast is not practical, certainly not in just two days.
This has been studied. The papers presented at the Election Verification Network conference(s) demonstrate that an audit, which is much like a recount, is expensive and does little to increase the certainty of the results. And when electronic (digital) casting and counting is involved, it's impossible.
https://electionverification.org
The best strategy remains the Australian Ballot (private voting, public counting), paper ballots, precinct-based counting of the votes when the polls close.
[1] http://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/study-finds-no-evidence-... [2] https://www.brennancenter.org/issues/voter-fraud [3] http://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/05/us/voter-id-laws-donald-tr... [4] http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2016/oct/...
To be fair, most of the problems we are currently having seem to revolve around gerry mandering with potential issues arising in the future involving tampering with electronic voting.
That doesn't mean voter supression, identity theft, and other forms of tampering aren't legitimate concerns though.
For example, heres article from MSM that investigates people who have been dead for years are still voting:
https://www.google.com/amp/losangeles.cbslocal.com/2016/05/2...
There is rhetoric now as though most or all voting is subject to this kind of fraud, that the fraud is massive. It just isn't. That doesn't mean it doesn't exist or shouldn't be stopped, but threats must be dealt with proportionally to the degree that they are threatening. Your reaction strikes me as disproportional.
Ignore intent and focus on prevention, like a QA/test person would. I'm kinda thick headed, so it took me too long to figure this out on my own.
It doesn't matter why something happens, only that it happens.
One side assumes the problem is huge, especially when they lose, and wants to take effective measures to prevent it. This side sees opposition to common-sense security as confirmation that fraud is actually occurring and is actively supported by the other side. The refusal to solidly secure things may or may not actually matter to the results, but it sure fuels suspicion. After all, why allow doubt about correctness unless you actually are doctoring the results?
We'd be better off if we could clearly demonstrate to the losing side that the loss is legit. Our low-security situation encourages the loser to claim that victory was stolen from them. That isn't good for keeping things peaceful.
The sources I provide clearly demonstrate that it is not an unknown problem. I would agree that it is a problem whose scope is not fully understood, but when you have something that doesn't seem like a big problem to most people, it's hard to argue that you should spend lots of time investigating it/divert resources to it. Since people's perceptions of the system are changing now, maybe that'll change, too. It would be one of the few good things to come of this election cycle if so, provided the money spent and time invested are reasonable/proportionate.
> After all, why allow doubt about correctness unless you actually are doctoring the results?
Like another poster said in this thread: Because you don't know better. Because you don't care. Because you don't think it's necessary. Because you can't afford to. Because it's not what the law says to do. Malice should be the last, not the first assumption.
You use the term "refuse" a lot in your comment; I don't think this is a matter of "refusal," so much as it is a matter of "nothing/nobody is telling us to." The government doesn't do things unless the people force it to do things, or unless those things are absolutely and unquestionably in the best interest of the people in government (and even then, it doesn't always act until the law compels it to).
Generally, I just think this issue is less sinister and more typical of the American political system than people think it is these days.
Second, you're statement "Malice should be the last, not the first assumption" is fundamentally incorrect. You shouldn't make any assumptions, you should look at the facts. While the intent may be benign, the effect is wide spread distrust, which is not and should be addressed accordingly.
I do not buy your narrative about media bias. I think it's ironic that you are standing on "we need hard facts and data" while providing none to support the idea that media is as biased as you say, only innuendo and an appeal to "the tech community."
You claim to be data driven, but when I provide data, you summarily throw it out, do not replace it with any of your own (or even an assertion that none exists), and make vague assertions about media bias instead.
> Second, you're statement "Malice should be the last, not the first assumption" is fundamentally incorrect. You shouldn't make any assumptions, you should look at the facts. While the intent may be benign, the effect is wide spread distrust, which is not and should be addressed accordingly.
I'll address this in concert with your reply above:
> It doesn't matter why something happens, only that it happens.
It does matter why, because if you want to fix it, you have to know the cause. If the problem is a problem of perception, that is fixed differently than if the problem is with the system itself. Data is meaningless without context.
Facts and figures and studies can be produced, but unfortunately that's not enough to convince people -- and that's on both sides. As much as we'd like to be, we're not perfectly rational actors, and much less so in aggregate. The existing system isn't simple or transparent enough for people to trust. That's what we need to work on.
There exists today a large group of people who will disregard anything the government or "mainstream media" says as false, regardless of who says it or what the statement is. What do we do about those people?
I want to believe that it's solvable, because the vast majority of people I meet day-to-day are good people. I'm not willing to accept the alternative.
I do think a big part of it has to do with figuring out how to talk about contentious issues, of finding common ground (no matter how narrow), with people we might disagree with on other issues. We can't let our disagreements get in the way of making progress on our common goals.