Hacker News Reader

Comment by gshulegaard | Hacker News Reader

I don't know:

> THIRD, a requirement that for every new federal regulation, two existing regulations must be eliminated.

Is scariest to me given a Republican controlled Congress. The one sided control makes me nervous.

Congress doesn't write federal regulations. Executive branch agencies do, within very broad guidelines that Congress has put in the statutes empowering those agencies. A lot of what Trump is proposing here can be done without any Congressional action at all; it's just a matter of changing the priorities of the agencies who write the regulations.

Of course, doing that is a much, much bigger job than I think Trump realizes.

This is fantastic. That's exactly how it should be. Otherwise over decades you end up with regulations that stifle all forms of entrepreneurship and creativity.

What is a unit of "regulation"? I can pack five thousand onerous rules into one document and eliminate two documents that contain guidance with very minor impact. Is that a net gain?

And in this way you end up with 0 regulations, which I assume we are supposed to consider a feature, not a bug?

One regulation, at least you'd still have that.

Next time you write a line of code, you have to delete two others.

What would happen if we applied this for 4 years on an existing codebase, such as the Linux Kernel?

Most likely support for obscure devices would disappear.

To be fair, that's already starting to happen[0]. do you think it would happen faster than it is today?

0. http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=MTI0OTg

People would fix the low hanging fruit and leave the hard/hairy parts that need work the most.

True - but then eventually, everyone would have to focus on the hard/hairy parts, no?

Yup. That doesn't mean that it's not worth taking care of the easy bits first.

It's nonsense. Measure regulatory burden by number of rules is absolutely arbitrary.

This document contradicts that every other sentence after that. Almost all the bills he proposes are regulations, the executive orders... regulations. He proposes to overturn about a quarter as many things as he wants made law or executive order.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com