Wikibollocks: The Shirky Rules
whimsley.typepad.com
whimsley.typepad.com
It seems digital media analysis and the media studies derived from them share this mild case of schizophrenia, or put another way a case of academic attention deficit disorder, the nature of the commentary is similar to the environment in which it is conceived.
I probably muddled what i was trying to say, but when you actually slog through a scholarly work (of say historical analysis) that presents an exhaustive attention to details, and reference you are struck by a wholly different kind of academic style, one that seems increasingly old school and unfashionable, which is very sad.
This mode still exist in the hard sciences, but in certain humanities it is viewed with suspicion, even disdain, at least that is my anecdotal observation.
It can be summed up as brilliant ideas, that fall apart due to lack of rigor in research.
The insidious part of this is that brilliant ideas and pithy quotes and the essays that result from them are so memorable, that in a way the bar for research disproving them is even higher that it would be if the statement in question was some dusty historical or physical science hypothesis.
Then again, the philosophy underpinning all of modern science was supposedly delivered by an angel:
There's a lot that imo really has problems in the other direction. A huge part of modern media studies is obsessively empirical, not publishing a paper unless it has a study and a p-value (see e.g. all the people publishing papers on MMOs). Empirical research can often be great of course, but I feel there are significant areas where nobody's really done the conceptual or philosophical work: just reporting the outcomes of studies is very surface-level knowledge, not really getting at mechanisms and relationships and how or why they exist.
Argument by analogue, and story-telling, reminds me of what I found unsettling about freakanomics and gladwell's work. Not that I didn't enjoy those books, I did. But I was oftentimes only left with the story.
Of course, there's probably an irony in the fact that I drew a trend from merely four anecdotes as well...
I disagree with the reasoning that "spoofs and pastiches" belong to the "complex business model" set of videos and not the "creative amateur" set.
Occasional badly-informed opinions, worth exactly what you pay for them. Mostly technology and politics with a pseudo-philosophical twist.
Is that meant to be funny or protect the author from criticism?
Because a friend would say he's humble and funny, and an enemy would say he's deceptive and ignorant.
Then again, I don't personally know him...
I recall it being damned expensive to buy, but you should be able to borrow it from a well-appointed library.