> My desired location is in an anomalous realestate market.
> the arguments for buying never made sense to me
Well, there you go. I live in a market that's anomalous in the other direction: there's exactly one four-bedroom house advertised for rent in the city at the moment, and its price is about 20% higher than the mortgage would be.
(Mortgage >> rent implies a really strange market where the landlords must be experiencing negative ROI?)