Very, very, very few people that hold untrue facts in their mind are open to re-evaluating those facts.
No thank you.
EDIT: added the word "NOT" above.
Very, very, very few people that hold untrue facts in their mind are open to re-evaluating those facts.
No thank you.
EDIT: added the word "NOT" above.
Or maybe... just maybe... you're the one with untrue facts in your head, and his true facts collide with your untrue ones?
Unpossible!
The charitable way to read the comment is that a particular person he talked to was unconcerned by facts, and that this is a common problem with heated/divisive discussions. (This jives with my experience that most people don't care what's true, they just want to make socially approved noises.)
It doesn't matter if it's trump.
Or Hillary.
Or global warming or vaccines or JS or Modi or Putin or any number of things.
Most human beings don't tend to change their opinions when directly engaging in discussions.
The only people who change their positions are people actively trying to change their views.
The real trick to changing an opinions is to stop trying and start listening.
That's anathema to most people.
Your statement made more sense before the edit.
I think the website makes it clear that this is for people who are willing to listen to each other. Once that mutual willingness is there, I believe a discussion like this can be very profitable. (Actually, I do not only believe so, I know so from many personal experiences.) Of course you are going to have some bad apples in the lineup who are going to start nasty arguments, but I think the presentation of the website is such that these should be kept to a minimum.
A big thank you to the Accord team from me - in a political age defined increasingly by the demonization of other political/social opinions (something all sides engage in), we desperately need more polite, levelheaded discussions.
ME: British are against the muslim immigration because large percentage of muslims hold these undemocratic antiwestern beliefs: A, B, C, D, and they don't assimilate.
THEM: You're a racist / bigot. Shame! Shame! Shame!
I'm thinking of the 2nd person asking questions about the first argument, asking for evidence, facts, definitions etc, in an attempt to understand.
I ask as a British citizen who has failed at all attempts to try to understand the other side (and I could take blame of course. I still seek a solution)
A perfect argument would indeed require both sides to show the evidence, to use logical constructs, to refute the opposing ideas. And some definitely try.
However, I agree with you that all elements of the political spectrum are engaging in some pretty heavy name calling these days. One reason why Accord's project is so important.
To that extent I wholeheartedly agree. If you can't even agree on the base data, how can you build a conclusion?