But, yes, I agree. User hostile - and there are plenty of comments on Google's product forums to support that viewpoint.
Can you explain why AMP is a good idea? I still don't really understand it, I'm afraid.
There is no doubt that AMP is fast.
The other angle is how it reinforces Google's position for advertising, analytics, search, video and such. On one hand you could say it is "evil" because they are a monopolist, but the status quo is so bad when ad networks are weighing you down with multiple tracking pixels, malware service, etc.
If you wanted to build a mobile directory or search engine you could make your own AMP server and do something like what Google does.
Google gets more gain out of it than anybody else because of their dominance of that space, having proven monetization methods in place, etc. If the shared Google result is displayed on the Google network they can reuse the same TCP connection, which gives them an edge.
You are free to build fast pages with web technology, in fact that is what I do. Most people seem to have a hard time with it, particularly because they include a huge amount of stuff using Javascript inclusions from third party sites and this is a critical technology since this is where the money comes from.
The actual reason for AMP is that it gives Google control: the good side of that is that companies have an outside check on performance — think about how many companies exist where internal politics means that “this will hurt SEO” will be listened to but “this page is too heavy” coming from inside will be ignored — and the bad side is that anyone who adopts it is binding their technical capabilities closely to Google's decisions.
AMP is faster than the alternative.
That's not true unless your site already has a huge exposed vulnerability. It's also irrelevant to the discussion of how a search engine could provide an opt-in feature which you could choose to enable.
> AMP is faster than the alternative.
Do you have any data to support that assertion? Remember, you're replying to a thread about possible standards-based alternatives but Google has never implemented that, so we all we can say is that AMP is faster than not doing anything at all. We don't have any data saying that the solution to web performance problems is a bunch of proprietary markup and JavaScript. I've certainly found AMP to be slower as often as it is faster, because the proprietary markup means you have a bunch of resource requests which will be delayed until ~125KB of JavaScript loads and executes whereas a standard <img> tag would have started the same transfer without that delay (see e.g. https://www.webpagetest.org/video/compare.php?tests=161129_X... where the non-AMP version starts rendering over a second faster on an iPhone 6 over LTE).
As an example of how this could be different, imagine if Google simply started aggressively using measured page-load times and transfer size with the same weight they currently give to AMP, giving all publishers the same incentive to reduce things like the massive amount of ad-related JavaScript they traditionally serve, and started serving rel=dns-prefetch/preconnect/preload hints for the top-n search results (or on mouse hover states, etc.). That might not be quite as fast as the best-case for AMP but I suspect it would rapidly get into the territory where the user benefit is diminishing compared to the benefits of not dictating a restricted tech stack.
That last part is pretty important because AMP is not without cost: it breaks the sharing UX on mobile devices, desktop users get a mobile-optimized page which isn't as good for their devices, and most importantly it limits you to the subset of functionality which they choose to implement. It seems risky to push everyone towards a single company's view of how the web should work rather than allowing independent experimentation and optimization for different types of content and users.
- Cut off third party ad networks
- Reduce bounce rates from Google.com to outside sites
> Reducing bounce rates that are due to slow pagespeed is probably a good thing!