A sufficiently small government can be funded without an income tax, as history shows us.
A sufficiently small government can be funded without an income tax, as history shows us.
It's a recursion which has plagued the world for centuries.
The whole system can in theory be replaced with non-profit investments funds, which crowdfund social projects.
You dont even have to elect 'leaders', because citizens will be involved full time in running things (by guarding their investments) similarily to how they now waste time on Facebook.
But good luck changing anything without a nuclear apocalypse :) There are a lot of people who like the system the way it is and they won't give it up because us idealists want a better world for their children..
It really is an old argument. The arrogance of thinking that a small handful of elites should "run things" for the stupid commoners dates back at least as far as Plato's era and the idea of the "philosopher king".
Not sure if you're calling me arrogant or not, by all means I'm all for a new society in which people govern themselves as much as is technologically possible.
I believe that the system of 'elites' has been taken to an extreme globally and is one of the main reasons for the dire state of the whole system, including climate change, pollution, financial bubbles, etc.
What I'm saying though is that the 'old' system is built to perpetuate itself - they have power - military, police, justice...
And they won't give it up for some shiny new ideas, even if it means self-destruction.
I live in a country where we're not ok seeing people in the street and we're not ok seeing sick people who can't pay for medecine. I'm ok with paying taxes for those. What I'm not ok with is having people who use what we all pay for, then try to not pay for their part by evading taxes. If taxes is a problem for you, I'm pretty sure there are a lot of countries where you can move and that you will find adequate.
> people who use what we all pay for, then try to not pay for their part by evading taxes
But tax is not flat rate. The poorest often pay the least tax, but use public facilities the most; how is that "pay[ing] for their part"?
What has unemployment to do here? Are you saying that with no taxes, there is no unemployment? (for reference, I live in France)
> how is that "pay[ing] for their part"?
This is exactly paying for their part: everybody feel their effort as the same as their neighbor. And if you're about to say that poor people are abusing that and stay poor on purpose: find me a poor person that refuses a billion dollar if you offer them. Or even who refuses to earn more than currently, for the matter.
Make statements like "I live in a country where we're not OK seeing" only if the solutions to these problems in your own country is stable - many European countries aren't clearly so, so the idea that these are just matters of public choice isn't fair.
Choice WP snippets:
"The French healthcare system was named by the WHO as the best performing system in the world"
"the rising cost of the system has been a source of concern"
The latter seems to be a common problem, and is what I mean by "stable".
> everybody feel their effort as the same as their neighbor
If this is true, do the rich use public services proportionally more wrt their tax contributions?
What does "feel" the same as their neighbor mean - a service costs $10, my neighbor pays $1.50, I pay $8.50, which is fair because I earn more? Who says I didn't work harder in order to earn more; Where does my neighbor share the burden in that? Maybe I contribute more value to society, which is why I earn more; Why is my reward for that reduced?
Aren't the fixed tax band fairly arbitrary? Let's actually work to reduce corruption and un-fair money-making, but otherwise tax people in proportion to the value they get from society.
If we assume a fixed, minimum cost of living, a richer person can always afford more since they have more money.
What can be afforded, and what is fair payment for public services used are different things. OP was talking about "paying fair share" of public services used.
Also, comparing the very bottom with the very top is extreme. There are plenty more in the middle.
> diminishing marginal utility
What relevance it this to fair tax on individuals?
I live in Spain, there's no such thing here.
What I propose is for people to have the ability to specify what their taxes are spent on. I dislike it when government wastes tax money on useless or corrupt projects, military, police, surveillance and other such things, which I personally would not support if I had the choice.
I would invest that money in more schools, hospitals, etc.
This would change what we now call 'government' from raw money spenders into project managers who seek public funding.
Citizens can fund public projects from their phones and get involved in the debates, votes, etc.
That's real-time democracy - no need for elections or politicians, just technocrats who monitor the needs of society and ask people for funding.
Think about it for a while and you'll notice lots of positive consequences of such a system.
That being said, thinking having a central government is the problem is extreme. Your examples and suggestions simply demonstrate we need more democracy, not less government.
EDIT: yeah, thinking about it twice, it definitely needs to be only a part of the taxes you can choose where to allocate, and thus some kind of administration to decide about the rest. Think about this scenario:
You live in a country where unemployment is high and sickness are low. People will naturally spend most of the budget in reforms allowing for more jobs, because they, or people they know, are unemployed. But there are sick people, with no budget. If the amount sick people pay in tax is enough to heal them, that's ok. Now, imagine it costs more, like, you need expansive medicine to cure a virus. People will still invest in job reforms, until they hear about a big epidemic that threatens them. Only then will they start to allocate taxes to healthcare, which will cost way more because the epidemic will be already there.
With no fixed budgeting failsafe, such a system will naturally create a lot of epidemics, and other problems caused because small problems are not fixed early enough. Also, those who have rare problems are screwed and will fall first, so you'll probably having a less creative and risk taking society.
Also, things that don't affect majority of people will probably never get enough funding. For example blindness. How many blind people do you know? And do you think anyone is going to be convinced that a single kickstarter-type campaign is going to solve it? I imagine even the most motivated donors will start considering dropping out after 2 decades of spending money when they've produced no measurable results to curing blindness (or paralysis, cancer, etc).
EDIT: In fact, the more I think about it, the more it becomes obvious this sort of system couldn't work on a massive scale (such as a scale necessary to do what a government does). Each person is probably only going to be able to comprehend the need to address perhaps hundreds of specific issues. But my guess is that governments, in total, deal with probably 10's of thousands if not more different types of issues on a daily basis. Not only that but those issues that a citizen does comprehend, will he / she need to keep up with how each issue is being addressed? After all, otherwise I'm potentially just throwing money down a rat hole. Sounds like more than just a full-time job on its own. How would one find enough time to do that and still make money to bring home to their families, etc..
I think dogmatic positions are almost always wrong :)
Your being OK with taxes is completely irrelevant to anything outside of yourself. As long as taxation is practiced the way it is here in the US (eg, enforced at the end of a gun barrel) it's theft, and it's immoral, no matter how noble the purported objective(s).
Eliminating taxation does not, however, preclude the idea of voluntary, collective funding for important causes, including the idea of a "social safety net".
If taxes is a problem for you, I'm pretty sure there are a lot of countries where you can move and that you will find adequate
That is also irrelevant. There's no reason the people being robbed should be the ones to move. A better idea would be to construct a social system based purely on voluntary exchanges and interactions altogether.
How so? The government is collecting the money you owe them. And you owe them money because every single day you use and benefit from things the government has funded, such as as infrastructure, police protection, fire protection, military protection and much, much more. It's true that there is no way to "opt-out" of those things but that's simply because it would be impossible to create a system where people can do so that is not massively and incredibly complex.
Besides, do you really want to live in a world where your house burns down because your neighbor has "opted out" of fire protection and their house fire spread to yours?
Admit it. Its socially-excepted extortion from successful where people always increasing welfare spending. I dont know why anyone have to demonize anyone. People are looking after their own self-interest. And successful after their own by evading taxes.
We do have usage-based taxes for things where we can calculate the usage relatively easily, such as tolls for roads. A lot of other things however have to come from your income, because that's the easiest method that, believe it or not, requires the least bureaucracy.
P.S. You can't opt out of police protection because... how would that work exactly?
Much much more... like launching invasions on other countries, giving policemen paid leave after committing brutalities, bailing out mega corporations, providing jobs it's near impossible to be fired from with no incentive for hard work...
The state is structured in such a way that you can't help but use what they provide. That doesn't constitute any kind of consent. If a cartel occupies your area, demands protection money, and provides some services - they are still a cartel.
I think this is very erroneous thinking. Just because a government currently does something, does not mean it cannot be done any other way. Nor does it mean someone against income tax is in favour of it not being done at all.
Imagine if someone proposed nationalising all food production to you, and you recoiled in horror, then they accused you of being OK seeing people starve on the street. It's dishonest.
What I'm not ok with is having people who use what we all pay for, then try to not pay for their part by evading taxes.
The very richest people do not pay income tax proportional to their wealth. The progressive taxation system is largely a myth - when you are very rich you have the means to find ways around byzantine tax rules and you will tend to tie up your wealth in assets.
If taxes is a problem for you, I'm pretty sure there are a lot of countries where you can move and that you will find adequate.
You could literally say that about anything a government does. If you don't like being sent to gulags, I am sure you can leave North Korea, etc etc. It's not much of an argument.
Those are the leaders, they're just 100% more self-appointed and unaccountable. Your whole scheme is just Bolshevism with the terminology changed.
Bolshevism excludes private property and implements the dictatorship of the proletariat, which is a different form of government.
What I propose is a system in which normal people are involved in day-to-day politics - with their votes and their money.
The representative system that most 'democracies' implement today do so because until recently there was no technical alternative to electing people to run things for everyone else, simply because everyone else didn't have the technical means to participate.
Now we have the technical means in which society can be run in a much more decentralised way, people can be consulted in real time using a 'society app' and they can 'invest' into social projects that matter for them - like schools or roads and so on.
What I'm proposing is bringing democracy into the 21st century.
I'm reminded of the UK's "Police and Crime commissioners", an attempt at getting democratic involvement in policing who get elected on turnouts of 15%.
Oh ya? Name one.
Not necessarily agreeing with the concept, but it only really works when taken to some extremes