> There were even reports of people's Gmail accounts being hacked.
This sounds suspiciously false - even if they are phones were forced to downgrade to A5/1 this should have no effect on TLS.
> There were even reports of people's Gmail accounts being hacked.
This sounds suspiciously false - even if they are phones were forced to downgrade to A5/1 this should have no effect on TLS.
I don't doubt the US (or German, or UK, etc) have the technical capacity to do such things, but would they risk it be discovered for such a "low" target as a natural site?
If true that probably means they have much more powerful tools at their disposal for "true emergencies"...?
edit: Furthermore Chrome/Firefox implement HSTS preload lists on which gmail.com is included. [0][1]
[0] https://cs.chromium.org/chromium/src/net/http/transport_secu...
[1] https://blog.mozilla.org/security/2012/11/01/preloading-hsts...
My reply contended that it's possible. A device running something other than a recent version of a modern browser is entirely susceptible to connection to Gmail over a non-TLS pipe or TLS to a MITM, especially when that device is using a fake Wifi AP.
Citing that the state of the art in browser technology exists does not change that point.
Do you agree it's possible the claim is true?
> Do you agree it's possible the claim is true?
HSTS preload lists are not new (the Mozilla blog I referenced above is dated 2012).
> The article said people were reporting that Gmail accounts have been hacked in an environment where malicious Wifi APs are prevalent. Your post said that report "sounds suspiciously false."
If it's a case of 'technically illiterate user entered gmail credentials on a wifi-login page' than that can happen on literally any wifi-AP. I'm saying that the claim that phones are being forced to connect to fake base-stations mounted on Cessna's (which is possible) is not at all substantiated by reports of people's Gmail accounts being hacked, the later just sounds like lazy journalism as another commenter has pointed out.
By the way, I wouldn't call these people technically illiterate. The way you're using that term sets a bar so high that it includes almost everyone. If many people were at that level of technical literacy, we wouldn't have needed HSTS in the first place.
Even for my 2FA GMail setup (where each non-2FA enabled app gets an app-specific password), doing IMAP MITM will get the app-specific password, which would enable further IMAP access.