I tried (bought) sendy.co and it seems quite buggy. I'm still looking for something self-hosted, where any SMTP provider can be plugged into, and that does not look like its 1993. As I have some non-techies that need to work with it.
I can get around that but the main thing preventing me from using it is there's no success stories associated to the application.
Sendy has dozens of unbiased blog posts, and even some posts where people are sending millions of e-mails without issues. That instills a lot of confidence in using it.
You would have to be a madman to trust an untrusted application with managing your email subscribers.
Have any of them done any audits on the code base and traced all incoming requests through Mailtrain vs their SES backend to ensure everything was delivered as expected?