Usually on interesting links i middleclick the comments-links and leftclick the link, so that i read the link first, close the tab and read the comments.
An extra page with most popular comments wouldn't be as interesting for me, as a comment without context (the link) is rather worthless. And if i first read the article i might be interested in all sorts of comments. Quite often, only because a comment has many points, it doesn't mean it's the most interesting.