Why schools should not teach general critical-thinking skills
aeon.co
aeon.co
That kind of reasoning is useful in any area in which you have to work out whether some propositions are true or false, or have to perform a thorough analysis of the cases that may occur.
It won't help you solve, say, a spatial problem ("can this cabinet be carried down this stairwell?"). That's a proposition with a truth value; if we already know that truth value, we can reason critically across that, and some related truth values that we also know.
The value in critical thinking is that students learn to avoid making inferential mistakes when working with facts and claims, not that they are gaining some powerful tool in a context-independent way that will make them more productive in any domain.