Indeed. It's one of the fundamental fallacies of design: The fact something is clear and easy for you does not mean that it's objectively clear and easy. You are not your users. http://uxmyths.com/post/715988395/myth-you-are-like-your-use...
I grew up using command line, I kept stubbornly using it for years after GUIs was ubiquitous, and I still use it regularly at work and at home. None of that means that it is the best tool available for this specific learning task.
> It's literally a diagram of the file system.
So is Windows Explorer or any other GUI file browser, in every way. If you put it in details view, it even displays the same data in the same way as a command line directory, except you can navigate it intuitively with a mouse.
When someone is learning what a file is, explorer shows both too much and too little information.
Where do you place your mobile while typing with both hands though ? Maybe in a casing so it can sit on your lower arm. Or a Velcro/burdock case so you can place the mobile on textile surfaces.
Who does computing outside of data center? I'm typing this on a laptop right now, but I wouldn't say I do any "computing" on it. Even at work, I would say that the actually amount of "computing" I'm responsible for (i.e. a program I specifically wrote to calculate some number.) is very low compared to simply text editing, web surfing, and music playing.
Throwing around this archaic and ill defined term, and then dismissing the phone as "a media consumption device" strikes me as elitist and out of touch. Is photography consumption? Clearly not, since it's production. Is media editing consumption? No. Is it computing? Well given that nonlinear digital video editors were big expensive machines several years ago, I'd say so, unless of course we're moving the bar. Is writing computing? 30 years ago it was. Do people actually write on their phones? Yes. Oh communication doesn't count? How about term papers? Do they do that? Yes, they do.[0]
I think you need to reexamine your biases.
[0] http://www.wsj.com/articles/look-mom-im-writing-a-term-paper...
As for what phones are capable of, I'm aware. But they are the wrong tool for the job. For the most part the are walled gardens where the only things you can do are what some app developer thought you might like to do. The industry is stuck in a regressive state where we are trying to limit users, not empower them.
They're the wrong tool for the job of creating and managing files in a filesystem. They're not the wrong tool for writing a Google Doc, or updating a Facebook status, or taking a photo and uploading it to Instagram. Arguing that we need to teach users paradigms like a command line is out of touch with what computers are to most people today.
We should be making tools that work with the way people use computers, not making users work at learning the tools we build.
That isn't empowering users, it's enslaving them.
You must mean an Apple watch you can speak to, and a Microsoft Hololens...
Stripping down the engine would be more akin to coding the programs themselves. This is more akin to saying that before someone drives they should know about the accelerator, brake and steering wheel, the basic tools that they use to interact with the car.
No, this is something in between, but an analogous system does not exist in cars. If cars had trim, like airplanes, that might be analogous.
'A file is where data is stored'
And
'a program is a collection of instructions for the computer to do something' are the basic levels of understanding one would expect.
I'd say it sounds a lot more like learning the basic theory of hydraulic brakes (because you shouldn't brake too much but rather switch to a lower gear when you drive down from mountains.)
Computer is not an appliance, it's a general-purpose problem-solving tool. It's closer to reading and writing than to dishwasher or fax machine. You can argue that applications are like appliances, and that makes some sense, but refusing to learn about the environment those applications live in makes you that much less able to do things that span multiple applications.