You can grab the CO2 from the atmosphere and thus produce (temporary) negative emissions. But then you need even more energy in the first place. So naturally you'd get the CO2 from somewhere where you already have large amounts of CO2, e.g. a coal power plant. So you have created a justification to keep the coal plant running (with a supposedly imperfect co2 extraction process). How's that going to work out in a supposedly CO2 free energy future?
Also it should be considered that the CO2 in the plastic isn't gone for good. Plastic has a limited lifetime and will eventually end up in a landfill or a waste processing plant where it'll release its stored carbon back to the atmosphere.
So if your process is "burn coal -> capture CO2 -> use CO2 to create plastics -> plastic ends up in waste processing plant" you have delayed the emissions from the coal plant and you can argue that you have used the coal in a more efficient way, but the CO2 still ends up in the atmosphere.