Should we criminalize difficult exam questions?
google.com
google.com
Answer: No. That author should only be liable in civil court.
"There's quite a lot of pressure to excel in high school and university. I wonder if getting an education is more dangerous than say smoking. What do you think?"
"Should games get upset when not played much? For example, a tetris-type game could show sad faces in the blocks when it is neglected."
And, my favourite (edited for brevity):
"Students should be taught to lie and cheat. These things require intelligence. Encouraging students to lie and cheat in school would improve their thinking abilities... You could reward the students whose cheating was successful with bonus marks. To get these bonus marks, students would need to fully disclose how they cheated after they got away with it. Their cheating techniques would then be made known to all students, who could then use them as ideas for more elaborate techniques... In the end, students may end up smarter and more honest."
Visibly agitated student: "Your test was badly designed! I only got an 80 on it!"
Me: "I accurately measured who understands the material and who does not. Everyone here knows what they know and knows some things they don't know. Also, you got the 3'rd highest grade and an A. What's the problem?"
Student: "But what about my self esteem? I never got lower than a 90 before."
So no matter how hard the average student may study, he/she would have little chance of making progress on such questions.
This could be devastating mentally -- and perhaps science will show that it eventually results in permanent brain damage.
First, this is probably factually false. I don't have studies to cite offhand, but it seems that the brain is immenantly trainable to virtually any specific task. Perhaps, just perhaps, many people do not have the innate potential to do Nobel Prize leve research, but I suspect anyone without a genuine mental disability can with time and determination master just about any undergraduate level topic.
If I am genuinely wrong and some people are not innately capable of passing a specific class, then the answer is still not to lower the standards so they can pass it. Rather that would mean (if true) that that person does not belong in that class. Perhaps they need to change majors or choose different electives, but lowering the standards will harm everyone else in that class.
Short story:I have a friend that had an average score of 98.5%. Can you imagine the pressure on him for every exam? A small mistake could cost him big. I on the other hand lost my "viriginty" long before, so I could actually focus on learning rather than on keeping a perfect score.
I think it's better that we strive for excellence even if we don't achieve than we strive for a false accomplishments (mediocrity).
Remember when you had to study for tests?
Remember when you knuckled down and did the work, or else flunked and were held back?
Yeah, say goodbye to all that and hello to the self-esteem regime. Emitting busloads of incompetents who feel good about themselves. Since the thing to aspire to nowadays is to get on a reality show, I guess they'll have all the skills they need regardless.
God bless America, huh?