Quarter of inmates could have been spared prison without risk, study says
theguardian.com
theguardian.com
The situation is not any better with law enforcement and prosecutors. Nobody gets excited when an elected prosecutor says 'I put 2000 people into a diversionary program this year.' and his political opponents go pick out the fringe cases where 1 of those 2000 went on to rob a bank and kill someone, and use that as justification that all of them should have been in prison.
The law enforcement officer that brags about how many people he 'put away' gets kudos and accolades, while the one that let them go stays at the bottom of the ranks.
None of this will change until we as society value rehabilitation over punishment and are willing to accept the small up-front and rather short term risk of recividism in exchange for a long term benefit to society as a whole.
The real culprit here is prosecutors that have very little interest in actual justice, but instead have a strong desire to win cases and secure harsh punishments. Private prisons don't need to lobby prosecutors and legislators to do these things. Prosecutors and law makers are all too eager to be "tough on crime" all by themselves.
I think there is a very tribal incentive with elected district attorneys who should instead by nominated by the local executive, with advise and consent by the legislative body. Making a prosecutor be a politician pretty clearly is itself a conflict of interest.
I think the only real fix is education.
DAs didn't pass Three Strikes. Voters did.
Take SpaceX for example, they have done more for space travel than NASA in recent years, not for want of intelligence in NASA scientists, but because SpaceX is streamlined bureaucratically in a way that, currently, NASA is not.
A bit sad, really, as public jobs are far more comfortable and secure, and so should be used by the administrators for greater performance output.
I'm not so sure about this.
It's the police/prosecutors that put people in there, and parole hearing folks as well - neither of which are 'private entities'.
So, the connection between 'headcount' and 'ownership' is not so direct.
It's entirely plausible that a small change in law could affect how many are actually put in prison.
Obviously - lobbying is an issue, but it's indirect.
Also - the punishment for small amounts of weed in most states is insane.
Likewise - the drinking age is crazy high in the US.
Some minor changes in the law could really quite radically affect how many people are in jail.
http://reason.com/blog/2015/06/02/are-for-profit-prisons-or-...
2. Is there is any evidence that they are lobbying for more or heavier prison sentences to make more money, because that's a pretty serious accusation. I would think that the lobbying money is actually going to get politicians to choose their prison service over public ones or their competitor's private prison. I think that allegations that they are lobbying to get more people into jail is a serious and unsubstantiated one.
> Is there is any evidence that they are lobbying for more
Prison guard unions regularly lobby against marijuana legalization.
https://www.opensecrets.org/news/issues/marijuana/
They lobby for prison expansion, more prisons.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/09/09/california-prison-g...
They lobby against parole.
http://reason.com/blog/2012/08/22/what-does-it-mean-that-pub...
Obviously most of this is at the state level. I live in CA and know more about CA. We have private prisons, just fewer.
So the title is misleading. This is not "without risk" but more "without meaningful risk".
>> “Very long lengths of stay in many many cases do not make people safer”
Who said that long sentences had anything to do with making people safer? The criminal justice system doesn't exist solely to promote safety. That's an outcome, but the system is there to enforce laws. Those laws are based on morality, religion, politics ... the promotion of public safety is only one of many reasons we lock people up.
Mostly, our criminal laws have been passed and grandfathered through without any scientific analysis re public safety. We lock people up because we want them locked up, even when we know it doesn't do society any net safety good. We have to accept that reality before we can set about decreasing sentences or eliminating oppressive laws.
Also, long sentences are at least measurable. In our efforts to reduce them we don't want to fall into even older patterns. Indefinite sentencing is far worse, opening the door to all sorts of evils. Indefinite sentencing is what happens when you start releasing the "good" inmates while keeping the "bad" locked up. Once that starts happening judges and juries might return to the dangerous assumption that they need to over-sentence.
Everybody involved in establishing sentencing policies.
The criminal justice system doesn't exist solely to promote safety. That's an outcome, but the system is there to enforce laws.
Just a nitpick, the conviction is the enforcement of the law. Sentences are something else, as you later detail, but also something that many many people study. You can say that judges have too much leeway, but then we see overcorrections into things like mandatory minimums and three-strikes laws, which sweep up too many low-level offenders who step a little too far out of line and receive severe punishments, not to mention the very selection of offenses which are subject to these requirements. You never see white-collar crimes in these statutes, but a bad financial criminal can wreak greater havoc on a person or family's life than many of the crimes under the 3-strikes and MM laws.
To a first-order approximation, "without meaningful risk" basically means "without risk".
So I think they were just trying to simplify.
No one can be spared prison without risk.