The question "What Makes a Senior Software Developer?" would only make sense given the context of what grades of engineers are present in a company. The definition will be different for a company with just 3 levels compared to one with 6 levels. I side with more levels. This is because, while we may argue that a "senior" engineer should have these 10 qualities, an engineer with 6 of those qualities is still better than one with just 2 of those qualities. So it makes sense to have the engineer with 6 qualities at a higher level than one with 2 of those qualities.
The question then becomes what are these N traits of a good engineer. The whole process of promotion and "senior"ity is irrelevant to that discussion. And I think most people here would already agree on those traits.