Another person that discovered evolution besides Darwin
bbc.com
bbc.com
"Wallace sent his ideas to the English naturalist Charles Darwin, with whom he often exchanged letters. As it happened, Darwin had been working for 20 years on his own theory of natural selection, partly inspired by his 1835 visit to the Galápagos Islands.
Darwin had not published his ideas, because he was afraid of a backlash. He quickly realised that Wallace's discoveries matched up with his own, and resolved to take the plunge. He decided to present both their papers at the same time, so that both men would get credit for having independently discovered evolution.
In the immediate aftermath, they both became famous. But after Darwin published his book On the origin of species by means of natural selection in 1859, he became known as the man who discovered evolution. Most people forgot about Wallace."
And he had good cause to be worried. Many initial responses were very negative. And although consensus shifted to firm agreement with him, a small but strong opposition exists to this day in multiple forms.
One of the biggest opponents pre-Darwin was Cuvier: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georges_Cuvier
Without one of those, natural selection stops. In theory, life might exist without one of them - if we live forever and stop having children, or if we all have the same amount of children, or if we design our children's genes artificially, etc.
> we have more non-human cells in our bodies than human ones.
I'm not the most educated in biology, but I thought if a cell is created in our body by our body, it is a human cell. Is this wrong to think?
Your body begins with a single human cell, then divides and grows. All those cells have your human DNA. But at some point bacterial cells also appear as part of your body, for example in your digestive tract, playing important roles you can't live without. Their source is not from your human cells, but they still form part of your body as a whole, in a sense.
I'm no expert by any means, but my understanding is that usually there needs to be some event that causes one species to diverge significantly. For example, if some percent of the population of some land dwelling animal becomes trapped on an island due to some geological activity, those that are better jumpers may be more fit for that new environment to survive like you stated (either to obtain food or avoid the common predators on that island). And thus over a period of hundreds or thousands of years in which they are separated on that island from the rest of their species, they will slowly evolve to be categorized as a new species.
But I can't see humans evolving to become a vastly different looking species (which is the layman's definition of an "evolved" species) since we are now a global population and our physical abilities do not determine our fitness to survive unless there was some global killer such as climate change which significantly changes civilization as we know it (e.g. we go back to being hunter/gatherers).
Keep in mind that it only needs to benefit survival a bit more than it hinders it. If it provides a big adantage, it will spread rapidly, but as long as it provides some advantage it stands a chance of surviving long enough to get a foothold and keep spreading.
Even if it doesn't provide any advantage, as long as it doesn't have a negative effect it still has a shot at spreading if it just happens to occur in a population that's otherwise successful.
> since we are now a global population and our physical abilities do not determine our fitness to survive
Our fitness also involves our ability to select a mate and have offspring, not just physical survival. It could very well be that our ability to select a mate will over long enough time scales be affected by appearance and changing cultural factors.
In some cases, traits can be disadvantageous in terms of survival but immensely advantageous reproductively.
This is a really important part of Darwin's and Wallace's theory - without taking it into account, many traits do not look beneficial, which would be quite a problem for the theory. More controversially (at least at the time), it illustrates that evolution is all about immediate advantage; there is no long-term plan or ladder of progress.
It's also important to consider the timescales involved in this--often hundreds of thousands to millions of years. However it's not necessarily a gradual, continuous process either. I read a lot 15-20 years ago about 'puncutated equilibrium', which basically states that species in an ecological region stay pretty constant until some relatively brief event (such as climate change or the introduction of a new predator) causes everything to adapt very rapidly to the new conditions, and then another period of stability sets in. Stephen Jay Gould wrote about this quite a bit for the lay reader and I believe did a lot of the theoretical development when he was a younger scientist. Whe I was in grad school, my paleontologist friends tended to scoff at it so it might not be in vogue but the books are still worth reading even if possibly dated.
The other observation that Gould promotes a bit is that evolution is quite chaotic and that most genera and species simply get out competed and die off instead of morphing into something new.
My hunch is that we're forcing quite rapid evolution right now, mostly due to habitat loss and substantial modification of ecosystems (i.e. monoculture fields, removal of alpha predators on land), and climate change will increase in importance throughout the next century. The real next movement of evolution will probably be the repopulation of earth by pollution-resistant creatures after we've killed ourselves and taken a good chunk of life with us.
I suspect he was a particular formidable opponent of evolution because his objections were based on factual evidence such as observations of the fossil record as well as the cited studies of mummified animals. It's equally impressive how many things he got right, such as the idea of extinction events at periodic intervals among many others.
Given the uncertainty of scientific knowledge at the time you have to wonder how well today's scientists would have performed in his shoes.
It's been awhile since I read Darwin's book, but he gave a lot of credit to his father at the beginning. From what I remember, evolution was more of his father's theory and Charles was young enough to make the trip, and lucky enough to have a father with deep pockets to pay for it.
Formally, the ship's surgeon was the expedition's naturalist, as was the practice in those days.
It's important we realize that scientific discovery always depends on the work of others ("the shoulders of giants" as the saying goes), but we also have to recognize true breakthroughs as well, and not just say Darwin "collected evidence for a popular theory".
actually, Lamarck's ideas have made quite a bit of a comeback - epigenetic studies being the prime example.
essentially what that's all about is there are DNA-affecting "things" (introduced by things like stress for example) that don't alter the DNA itself but affects how the DNA gets passed on to the offspring.
also (even though the scientific community gets all passive aggressive when this subject is brought up) - the truth of the matter is that while adaptation driven by natural selection is definitely "a thing" proven by experiments and observed in nature, the actual speciation driven by natural selection - not so much.
But I think it's worth stressing that the primary force that drives evolution is still very clearly natural selection. Not epigenetics, not genetic drift, not randomness, not "spanners" and other structural mechanisms, etc. It's remarkable that Darwin's idea has stood the test of time for so long. He just got it right. Where other influences exist, they tend to be interesting corner cases.
Also worth noting that the main exception to natural selection is sexual selection, which was also introduced by Darwin. We shouldn't over-idolize scientific figures, but Darwin was truly remarkable.
what makes you so sure of that?
Or were you asking why biologists are so sure? I'm not a biologist, but my understanding is that the evidence for natural selection is simply overwhelming on all levels (archeological, experimental, theoretical, simulations, etc.). Other evolutionary processes have interesting work behind them, but the burden of proof to show they matter as much as natural selection has just not been hit yet.
There is a small minority that think otherwise.
> I've read about so far is merely demonstrating adaptation of the species as opposed to a new species emergin
You seem to not understand what natural selection, spceciation or evolution are
If you're claiming that it has, the burden of proof is on you. That's how arguments work.
>> You seem to not understand what natural selection, spceciation or evolution are
I'm all ears.
https://youtu.be/D8m-ZEr9qV8?t=276
The full course is here - I cannot recommend it enough, the professor is pure gold(!): https://www.edx.org/course/introduction-biology-secret-life-...
Mendel was brilliant - but actually also a bit unlucky (or lucky?). All the traits he checked in his peas were on different chromosomes. He missed the deeper insights resulting form the confusion when inheritance of traits isn't independent, when genes were located on the same chromosome. That lead to the discovery of more mechanisms of inheritance... the random rearrangement of sections of chromosomes that takes place during meiosis.
>The proposal that one type of organism could descend from another type goes back to some of the first pre-Socratic Greek philosophers, such as Anaximander and Empedocles.[34] Such proposals survived into Roman times. The poet and philosopher Lucretius followed Empedocles in his masterwork De rerum natura (On the Nature of Things).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evolution#History_of_evolution...
Darwin described one mechanism (i.e. natural selection) that drives evolution.
Also, his two mechanisms were revolutionary at the time, and many decades later remain the most important factors in our understanding of evolution.
Yes, the general idea of evolution as "species change, rise and fall" is not a new one in Darwin's time. But today when we say "evolution" we basically mean "evolution by natural selection" which is Darwin's novelty.
But what was brilliant about Darwin's theory was that he proposed it while knowing basically nothing about the underlying biological features that enabled it--ie, discrete genes that are duplicated, sometimes with errors, in successive generations of individuals.
What blew my mind when I first understood these ideas was that given discrete genes, and given unequal chances of successful reproduction for various sets of genes, natural selection is essentially axiomatic. The rules of the game force natural selection to exist. There is no other way it can work. So I think it's fair to say that Darwin discovered natural selection. But not evolution.
By the way if you are interested in this topic at all and you haven't read "On the Origin of Species", do yourself a favor and seek it out. It's public domain so it's available all over the Internet and there are plenty of good printed editions available as well. For its age, it's remarkably clear and concise even for modern readers. It's well-written and the author takes a very humble approach to the topic. As an argument it's a fantastic example of building to your conclusion by step after concrete step of irrefutable evidence. And when Darwin had to get speculative, he was correct an incredibly high percentage of the time, so even his wildest ideas still hold up today.
care to cite a proven example of speciation caused by natural selection ?
To my knowledge, to date, the established experimental cases of achieving reproductive isolation (none achieving complete isolation btw)- no experiments demonstrated morphological differences between the "species" they produced.
Just because there's no evidence that natural selection leads to speciation it doesn't mean speciation in an of itself is not an important part of the evolutionary process unless of course you don't consider emergence of new species a part of that process.
Defining a framework/requirement for "something" to be called "something" is not a fallacy, removing the requirement because it doesn't fit your narrative is though.
If you did want a similar example in the same vein where speciation unambiguously occurred then one of Lenski's students just did a great experiment that shows that. I highly recommend reading it, it's a great paper. http://science.sciencemag.org/content/354/6317/1301
As far as the paper is concerned - divergence in virus populations based on their affinity for a specific receptor is nothing new, the very well researched influenza virus has been shown to do the exact same thing.
'Species' just an arbitrary dividing line humans invented. The reality is much, much messier. We might call something a different species, but it might still be able to breed with some other species. It might not ever do so because of proximity. It might not ever do so due to some minor characteristic throwing off mate signalling. Maybe it does, but the offspring aren't fertile. Maybe it does, but the offspring are only rarely fertile, like mules. There's this and a thousand other edge cases.
If you sit there and change an organism gene-by-gene, at what point do you think it becomes another species? If I flip a single gene and it affects reproduction, is it a different species? If I flip a thousand genes but it still interbreeds, is it a different species? Similarly, if you imagine going back through the line of your male ancestors, there's no point at which you can look between your great grandpappy^x and your great grandpappy^x + 1 and say one of them is homo sapiens and one of them is not.
That said though - we DO clearly observe speciation in the paleo records (assuming you won't be claiming that Eohippus == Modern Horse) so yes at some point these genome changes accumulate into a critical mass leading to speciation. Except that the "accepted" (there is obv some very solid criticism out there) narrative of natural selection being the only(or primary) vector of that change is yet to be proven after ~200 years of attempts to do so.
Speaking of flipping of the "reproduction gene" - if it gets flipped in a single specimen via a random mutation then he's obv stuck in terms of his reproductive ability, but that's a whole another can of worms no pun intended.
Sure, because we're looking at a big gap in time. An Eohippus never gave birth to a horse, though. There were intermediate organisms in between E and H. But as I said, there's no bright line you can point to and say one Eohippus is one species and its immediate progeny are another.
Put another way, if you have H(n), H(n+1), H(n+2), H(n+3)...and so on, there's no point at which you can say H(n+m) and H(n+m+1) are different species. But sure, you can compare H(n) and H(n+2000) and say they're different species. The line is inherently fuzzy. It disappears whenever you look too closely. Only when you zoom out is it present.
If you concede that natural selection leads to small changes, you have therefore conceded that it leads to speciation.
by this logic you can claim that "there's no bright line between the colors" because there are shades between them. there are discreet species in the Eohippus -> Modern Horse lineage however just like there's color white and color black. there are also "subspecies" out there like polar bears being essentially grizzly bears who adapted to living in the arctic but again this doesn't negate the existence of distinct species in their lineage.
>> If you concede that natural selection leads to small changes, you have therefore conceded that it leads to speciation.
and by this logic taking a CS101 class equals to graduating with a masters degree.
sympatric speciation (or rather lack of proof in this area) has been a thorn in darwinists' collective sides since the day "the origin of species" came out and is a huge hole in the whole "emergence of new species via natural selection" narrative. so huge as a matter of fact that after couple of hundreds of years of trying to figure out how it works they decided it wasn't all that important :)
There's only distinct species from the million-years-view. They only look distinct because the fossil record does not include every horse-ancestor who ever lived - the vast majority of them are gone from history. From the on-the-ground, year-by-year perspective, you have Eohippus very, very slowly looking more and more like a horse, so slowly that at no point do you really notice them changing from Eohippus to horse. We just arbitarily decided that the total gene pool back then was "Eohippus" and today it is "horse"; and even, say, the modern horse genetic pool is probably more diverse than any arbitrary Eohippus and many of its descendants.
The idea of a "species" in general only makes sense to us because almost everything that ever lived is dead.
> by this logic you can claim that "there's no bright line between the colors"
Well...there isn't. If you're dialing up light-frequencies a thousandth of a nanometer at a time from 400nm to 700nm, there's no point where you say "this is purple" and the next thousandth-meter adjustment you say "this is blue."
I'm not sure we're talking about the same things.
no, they look distinct because they belong to different species.
>> there's no point where you say "this is purple" and the next thousandth-meter adjustment you say "this is blue."
umm, there are discrete "blue" and "purple" points. to state the opposite is plain ridiculous :)
Darwin did some historical research on his predecessors for a later edition of the Origin. Wallace wasn't the only independent discoverer, though the others did not take it nearly as far. https://historiesofecology.blogspot.com/2013/08/predecessors...
They came with an explanation on what was the cause for it (natural selection). The theory has been improved and consolidated with the understanding of genetics since then...
Can the tropics be permanently colonized by Europeans, and particularly by men of the Anglo-Saxon race? This is the question that now occupies much attention in view of the mad struggle among the chief European Governments for a share of all those parts of tropical Africa and Asia still held by inferior races.