Pittsburgh is a strange place. I was thinking of buying a 2nd home in Shadyside about 4 years ago. I recently visited, and the homes that I was looking at have appreciated 3x! I spent some time talking to a lot of the locals, and they've not seen much change in the past 10 years. Pittsburgh has recently been ranked as one of the cities in the US with the highest inequality. I love Pittsburgh, but it's uneven.
Also surprised about Columbus and Pittsburgh. Not so surprised about Cincinnati and Cleveland.
Why Columbus over Cleveland?
I've never been to Columbus, but I went to college in Ohio and it seems people tended to move to Columbus and Pittsburgh, but obviously anecdotes aren't really data.
I went to college in Cleveland and have been all over PA and Ohio. Cleveland seemed much more dynamic that Columbus to me. And Pittsburgh was more dynamic than Cleveland.